Wednesday, February 22, 2006

IIM Calcutta - what happened?

Life is full of what ifs. What if I had attended IIM Calcutta instead of IIM Ahmedabad? The earth would not have moved of course, but it was one of the reasons I paid a visit to IIM C a couple of days ago. That, and professional curiosity.

IIM Calcutta is the 'original' IIM. The first one that came into existence. And yet, despite its MIT lineage, the glorious headstart and impressive enough alumni network, it is now considered to be behind not just IIM A but IIM B. What happened?

Well, I can't provide a conclusive answer but here are a few quick impressions. I know my IIM A background may be held against me but in my defence I would like to point out I write about bschools and hence make it my business to gather first hand information about as many as possible.

So this is about more than mera bschool tere b school se accha kaise. For the most part!

Joka, here I come
The postal address of IIM C mentions 'Diamond harbour'. In the course of a 200 buck taxi ride from Howrah station, you get the full 'experience' of Calcutta. Past the amazing British zamaane ka buildings including the Governor's mansion and the India Government Mint.

Past trams, markets and streets and streets of grimy looking structures which look like they haven't been painted since 1947. The scenery does not improve until you reach the IIM C gate.

Inside, is the most beautiful holiday resort you can check into for two years. Yes, I heard of the 'lakes' but imagined they would be ponds. This is breathtaking.

So are the flowers. I'm told they bloom, all year round.

The whole atmosphere is friendly, not intimidating. And here, yes, I will have to compare with IIM A. I remember the first time I walked into that campus, climbed up the Harvard steps and viewed the Louis Kahn plaza. I felt awe. I felt humble, insignificant.

In time, the maze of red brick buildings became more familiar and well loved than home. But a sense of this being a larger than life institution remained. That sense is missing at IIM C.

It may sound superficial to say that architecture can make so much of a difference in making or breaking a brand but it's true. When a newspaper has to choose a stock photo to go with any article on MBA, what does he or she do? 98 times out of 100 the photogenic IIM A makes it to print.

And with many other b schools from MDI to MICA also choosing the red brick look, it's more subliminal brownie points for Brand IIM A.

Looking deeper
IIM C grads themselves admit (and proudly so!) that the institute is extremely laidback. Not just in terms of atmosphere but academics. Even in term 1 only 75% attendance is mandatory.

In contrast no one would dream of bunking in the early weeks at IIMA. Weeks which feel like 'Survivor' episodes although it's rare for anyone to actually get 'eliminated'. But everyone has a few of those nightmares....

In 1991 - when I got my call letters - IIM B was also laidback and less competitive. Except it was considered to be far far behind IIM C. It was, in fact, known as the 'public sector IIM' because that's where its grads generally got jobs.

Then, several things happened. A director who was earlier a faculty member at IIM A fiddled around and made the B program more 'tough'. More importantly, Bangalore's rise as an 'IT capital' saw its stock as a city zoom while Calcutta was stagnating. Placements at IIM B caught up with A and C to a large extent.

Then, circa 2000, a Business Today survey made IIM B the 'no 1' b school in the country. A ranking no one believed but had its shock value.

The next year, A regained its no 1 position but B was now ranked ahead of C in almost every survey. Yet, IIM C and its alumni remained complacent. 'Who believes these surveys anyways?' was their defence.

Which is true but a combination of all the above factors led to a 'tipping point'. Students who had the choice started opting for IIM B to C. Guided by buzz from seniors and advice from coaching institutes.

Having recently visited IIM B I would say there is a sense of forward movement, new ideas, new initiatives on that campus. The PGPSEM program - a 3 year part time course for software professionals is a big hit and will soon be extended to Hyderabad and Chennai. IIM C too has several executive programs but none is a brand name as such.

IIM B has set up an Incubation centre funded by Infosys' N S Raghavan, IIM C has a centre for entrepreneurship and innovation but it seems to be a far more armchair variety than hands-on.

Bangalore being a far more happening city also has an impact in terms of attracting faculty. The faculty list at IIM C is over 90% Bong. Now you can argue that is because Bengalis are one of the few communities naturally inclined towards academics. But the faculty at both IIM A and B is far more mixed.

So it does appear as if sentimental attachment towards Calcutta might be a deciding factor for an academic choosing to work at IIM C. And that very factor may put off others. A friend who taught at IIM C for some time found the city rather dead and oppressive.

That's changing, with Calcutta - and Bengal in general - now playing 'catch up' with the rest of India. But the Joka campus also needs to join that game.

Er, world class?
Whatever the intellectual prowess of IIMC may be, some of the infra structure sucks big time. The hostels are shocking - ancient, lower middle class looking structures.The rooms are tiny- you can barely fit in one bed, and study table. The corridors are full of wooden racks where junta's underwears and banians hang to dry.

Yeah, one of the hostels is 'co ed' (but there's a separate wing for girls - they don' actually have rooms next to each other). That one seems to have rooms with modest balconies. But the overall impression is 1960s, Marxist style living quarters. Peeling paint, rust, lack of maintenance.

IIM A dorms were, in contrast, far better. Even there, much needs to be done to upgrade the old campus housing upto the standards of the new campus. But at IIM C I think entire hostel blocks need to be demolished and rebuilt.

Meanwhile, adding a few modern amenities like a washing machine and mini fridge wouldn't hurt. To attract international students - as IIM C hopes to - these changes will be absolutely necessary!

I am sure had I joined IIM C I too would have fallen in love with the place, mosquitoes et al. I too would have fine memories of the 'Howrah Bridge', friends made, times shared etc etc.

I know a bunch of you are going to be quite upset by now... And that the average IIMC grad believes he or she is special, creative and different compared to the supposedly driven, structured and soulless types from IIM A.

But, to a dispassionate and outside eye, there is a lot that can and must be done to the campus. Rankings aside, IIMC needs to regain its clout, become a leader in certain chosen spheres. Right now it appears content to follow where others dare to tread.

A quick example: IIM A starts a PGP X program (1 year MBA for execs with 7-15 years experience), IIM C follows a few months later. Does it matter who gets there first? Hell, it does!

Perception is reality when it comes to any kind of brand. And right now IIM C seems more slothful than swift. More content to rest on past laurels than carve out a vision for the future. It's time the institute and its alumni wake up and kick some serious butt.


  1. Rash...I guess the points you have raised are hardly of any concern to a common aspiring B-School Grad.

    These comparisons are obnoxious or rather ridiculous to say the least.I think it's time you stop raising such issues on your blog.

    Come on grow up now and stop that Lalita G type meri saree uskee sari comparisons...

  2. Ab well, you know something yaar... it's like when an IIMA Alumnus goes and tours IIMC and then says, 'look, I dint really like it', however unbiassed the opinion might be, it still sounds odd.

    May be all you have said is kind of, from a very neutral point of view, but as a reader, anyone can feel a lil bias somewhere. NO, I haven't been to either of these institutions. I am happy here in the jungles of IIT Madras. But of course, it would be hard for me, to not find things in other IITs which IIT Madras is proud to to have. I guess, you kind of got what I kind of wanted to tell.

    In a sentence, this blog was not for you to write though it's a different issue that you ob write well.

  3. Very frank opinion..

    More than the post by Rashmi I liked the comment by Ajit chouhan. Its not because I am an MCP its because wht he said is absolutely true

  4. Going purely by your account I would choose IIM C over IIM A. To be driven and structured is a personal trait. dont think I need a school to teach me that. And God forbid the day I become soulless.

  5. hi Rashmi,
    You have portrayed the correct image of IIM C.But i think that is the effect of laidback Bengali culture. When you visit Kolkata you cant even believe that this is a metropolitan city. Except the park street & Salt lake area,everywhere you will find old buildings. Everywhere Tramlines are passing through the road & these Trams dont serve any purpose.They are so slow that even a walking person can overtake them.If you dont know Bengali in Kolkata, then you are gone because people dont want to communicate in any other language.The worst thing about the city is Daily Strikes.You go to Kolkata & find yourself trapped in a traffic Jam beacuse there is some stupid rally going on.IIM B has excelled not only beacause of its tough curriculum but mainly due to the rise of Bangalore city.
    But whole of this aesthetic & culture thing doesn't count bcoz it is still one of the best B-Schools in India.IIM C has best Finance faculty & it is only bcoz of this reason it has more foreign placements in Investment Banks(most craved job nowadays) than IIMA & IIMB.So, people are more than happy in the end & for that they are even willing to go for two years Vanvaas in this laidback city.

  6. Rashmi,

    I agree to many of the things you have said, but at some places you have got your facts wrong. Unfortunately, we have 75% attendance all through the six terms.

    And perhaps being laid-back is not all that bad a thing for IIMC if I get a better chance to decide what I want to do with my life than try doing the 'in' thing. I am of the school of thought that too much of drive to do (Comparitively) well makes one follow the herd.

  7. whoa!!
    Way to go Rashmi, the facts are infallible.
    In spite of the obvious lacunae identified, if IIM-C junta do well in life, as they are, .. well we're probbly you know .. hardier .. look it doesnt matter how the buildings are .. our networks within campus and friendships across batches are much stronger .. thats what matters in the end .. the rest evens out. in the long run we're all dead rats anyways

  8. Rashmi,
    I am a regular reader of all your posts, but this is my first comment, because I dont agree with you. What you say may be true, but somehow u mixed up the story by bringing in trivial comparisons. And somewhere the message got muddled. And yes I am from IIMA. So I am not biased.

  9. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

  10. Hi Rashmi

    Every now and then some post of yours appalls me .. earlier posts 'chote chote shehron se' and 'shud IIMs go global' fall in this league .. i really cannot understand the objective of this post ... may be it was abt 'influence of IIMA on B-School architecture' or about IIMA getting ranked no. 1 in business magzines survey ...
    I remember that a few weeks ago u had criticized international magzines for their B-School ranking methods to be improper ... and today u have accepted indian rankings easily especially when IIMs themselves have decided to keep themselves away from these rankings.
    Do u really think that Harvard, Wharton and Sloan comapre themselves .. they dont ... coz they know that they are different institutes with different philosophies ... so why cant we stop comparing IIMs and rather educate the aspiring students about how are these institutes different ...
    You've also praised IIMA for its 'survivor series' like sleep depriving 1st term .. but what about an entire second year when ur grades dont count for placements .. the point here that u consider IIMA as a benchmark ... so many years into the industry we expect something like 'what they don teach at IIMA from u' and not those endless IIMA is the best sagas ...

  11. Rashmi,

    You are right in every aspect of what you have said. The infrastructure DOES suck. The hostels DO need demolition. The washing machines DO need to be there. The faculty is most definitely bong.

    But I think you are going a little too far. Yes, we are laid back but we are creative. As you said, we are not structured in everything. We are not number crunching machines. I WOULD GIVE YOU THE BENEFIT DOUBT IN THE AREA THAT WHATEVER LITTLE CREATIVE THAT AN IIMA GUY DOES IS PUT THROUGH GREAT PR. That's where we suck. Loads of people doing so many great things but we never care to advertise.

    As for what a B-School ought to give, it is more than just jobs. I so wish I could tell you the things that happen here. I will bet my life on the fact that you would never even imagine that such a thing could actually happen at a B-School. And that's why we are not structured but creative.

    IIMC gives you a life. A time to remember. And TRUST ME, IN IIMA's CASE THERE ARE NO LOSERS IN THE SURVIVOR SERIES, AT IIMC THERE ARE. You will never be able to gauge the pressure that the first few weeks (in fact the whole of term 1) put upon you. I would so much want you to come and study here just for those first few weeks.

    Just for the record, there is an upgradation plan in the offing. So hopefully the next time around you land up here, your camera will be looking at things more photogenic than clotheslines and corridor windows.


  12. Hats off 2 u Rashmi !!!! I'm highly disappointed by the way u put up your point.
    There are always two ways of looking at things or anything in life. A glass of water is either half empty or half full, depending on what you choose to see in it.
    Well according to you some ( IIM - A's ) may be lucky to have the grass beneath their feet, and you mean to say some others may fret & fume and look at the neighbours and envy the green of the grass on the other side.

    These are the attitudes of the mind. I can't understand what the point u want to put forward. These sort of comparisons are for which kind of junta......U need not feel nervous as hell about IIM - C's tomorrow. Look at the horizon and its vast expanse, get absorbed by the feeling.

    This campus is our successor's legacy, Amanat, just as you nurture your daughter and help her to grow into a beautiful lady( i don't know u've one or not )only to give her away to another man another family.

    Here we came 2 nurture ourselves, not to see how d buildings are and what kind of infrastructure we've.

    Thanxxx 4 ur suggestions anyways.. we always give others our welcome hand............

  13. Nice pictures-the only thing I liked about the post.

    But whatever happened to your arguments, Rashmi. If you do present facts and use them to draw out arguments for or against any issue,there has to be an attached "so what" to it.

    IIMC doesn't have a system in which girls rooms are next to guys. You mind it...So what? As a reader, why do I think it makes any difference at all ???
    IIMC does not have spic and span, hotel like accomodation. So what? The faculty at IIMC is 90% bong...So what? Your arguments would make perfect sense if-

    1) The girls room not being next to guys adversely affects any kind of intermingling between sexes
    2) The hostels not being hotel like brings down student morale.
    3) Faculty being 90% Bong means that the faculty is not upto the par and the academic standards are comparatively low.

    All of this, sadly, isn't the case. I am missing your point or is there any point at all in this whole post ??

  14. Rashmi, Your blog is one of the most widely read blogs in the country. If I'd known that you were coming to Joka, would definitely have made a point to meet you. Your views on IIMC are pertinent, but also a present a certain superficial case of judging a B-School. I am not going to go into a point by point rebuttal or anything like that, but here are my views:

    1) Infrastructure, yes it is old compared to say IIMA and IIMB. But as you will know, infrastructure by its very own nature is cyclical, and always has a lag to the actual demand. Right now it might appear that IIMC is at the bottom of the cycle, but lot of activity is happening which is not visible on the face of it, new hostels, planning a theme for the Institute’s architecture and the likes. (Stuff about student underwear left out to dry, etc is crap.. honestly even you will admit. People who wear clothes and are in the habit of getting them cleaned regularly will definitely have to dry them somewhere.) Fridges are there, maybe you didn’t notice them. Washing Machine, if you remember your first year Microeconomics courses at IIMA, it just boils down to the economics. If you can have the luxury of having somebody wash and iron your clothes and do room collection and room delivery for a cost lesser than what washing machines would cost, why on earth would anybody go for a washing machine.

    2) About being there first with the Executive MBA making a helluva lot of difference, well IIMC was the first IIM wasn’t it, but IIMA to be honest has managed to keep the No. 1 position for a long time. So timing will not make that big a difference, how the individual institutes position these programs though will. And that remains to be seen.

    3) IIMB's rise has got a lot to do with the tremendous rise of Bangalore on the Global Economy scene. Now Kolkata as a city is the next hot thing, and the general mood among people and administrators of the state/city is quite similar to what would have been in Bangalore 7-8 years ago. So the only way it can go is up.

    4) Faculty is Homogenous. I agree, that is a point. However even that is on the change; and besides because we have a predominantly Bong faculty, we have the best Economics and Finance faculty across any B-School in the country. (It has its plus points you see :P)

    5) About attendance, 75% is not Lax. The way we see it here, students are grown up adults. Almost 70% of them have prior work experience. They don’t require a stick to make them do something. They should be able to judge what is right for them and what is not. And you mentioned that IIMC is the most beautiful holiday resort one can check in for two years, well the campus might be as beautiful as a holiday resort (It is more beautiful if you come here during the winters when a dense fog settles down in the early mornings), but holidaying is the last thing people do here. Students here work as hard as any of the other two (IIMA and IIMB). Because if hard work is what had been missing, then placements at IIMC would have suffered terribly. But as you know from the rankings, year after year, IIMC comes out tops on the Recruiter perception part of the rankings done by all magazines. And if being laidback gives us a better perspective things (related to life and business) then its better that way. Because in the long run, business leaders are leaders for their ability to take a perspective and a stand, and not for their ability to slog 108 hours a week.

    6) Innovative in course structure, again I feel you are off the mark here. PGDCM, IIMC's computer aided management program (IIMB's recent PGSEM takes some inspiration from this) is 12 years old, much older than India's IT boom. So the people who thought up this program definitely saw the IT boom coming, and in a way contributed to it. IIMCs MCHV (Management Centre of Human Values - definitely the best piece of architecture across A, B or C) came up much before scandals like Enron and Worldcom made it fashionable to teach ethics in B-Schools. 'i2i' IIMC's flagship B-Plan contest was the first such B-Plan contest in India. So what is really your basis for claiming that IIMC is not innovative?

    Maybe you should have talked to a lot more students when you came down to Joka, or maybe you did. However your current report gives the impression that your IIMC visit was very superficial.

  15. hi rashmi,
    am from IIMC but spent last 8 months in IIMA with frnds(IITKGP junta and others)

    The comparisons stated above may be trivial or not, may be biased or not - this can only be decided by the person for himself/herself.

    If u thought putting it up on ur blog worthwhile u might have surely ur reasons for it as every1 who has commented upon it has his/her own reasons.

    But ne1 who chooses IIM A/B/C when he has an option is just making a choice and that is more important - people who exercise their choices and have the courage to live with it. That is what makes people who chose C over B or A different.

    Another point - as ridiculous as the 1s mentioned in the post but still here it goes - Why is it difficult to get a day zero summers in IIMA for ppl who are either non IIT/gals nowadays? Why does most (19 out of top 20 on average) rankers have to hv a gf on campus in IIM A?

    I mean there are contrasts even in these trivial aspects between IIM A & IIMC - the point here being that infrastructure is importnat part but what about the mindset and the change it undergoes stayin in IIMA and IIMC? - dont u think that is more important

    because u might be doing sales for HLL in a village ( the way u portrayed IIMC) or u might be working for an IB(need i mention smth here :p) - ur success will depend on ur ability to think and make choices and the courage to live with your choices - not that you should always keep ur nose in the air!

    ¬btw am not in HLL ( never was either )

  16. Though it is hard to miss your point that IIM-A and IIM-B rulez, but have you ever considered the fact that the people who join IIM-C over IIM-B are not all bongs or people who want to spend their two years being laidback? There may be people who want to discover themselves! I work in a company where my closest friend is from IIM-A and I find hardly any difference in the way we are treated by the corporate circles. It is time we stopped this self defeating game of one-upmanship, between our premier institutions. Instead of fighting over whose alma mater is the No-1 in India, let us build institutions who have varied experience offerings for the international students and not carbon copies of foreign universities and each other. And just for the record, some European exchange students to IIM-C were very happy in visiting whole of Calcutta and living for 3 months in IIM-C without speaking a word of Bangla. So instead of having arguments on frivolous grounds like need of mini fridges in rooms and building architecture please write on concrete issues. And please do not misuse the power of your blog to misdirect people towards a world of cut-throat senseless competition, rather than wholistic educational experience.

  17. It is IIM-C & not IIMC. That stands for Indian Institute of mass Communication. Ask any journalist! And it is since 1960s!

  18. Sorry rashmi!

    didn't like it. the arguments just don't hold. and who's this 'koolvibsflyinghigh'? he probably lives by the media feed of calcutta/kolkata. Go there and then comment.
    btw Trams are the best things to happen to any city.


  19. Rashmi

    I have been a regular visitor to your blog but I can't beleive that the same person has written this post! Did you outsource this one or what?!

    I will not even respond to the points you made, guess lots of people are already doing that.

    And what timing! Just when interview admissions are on and students will decide which IIM among A,B,C they want to join (if they get that lucky, that is). You sure did a good job.

    Sorry to say that this post seems more like one written by a 20 yr old unsuccessful IIM aspirant than one written by a (distinguished?!) alumna.

    Guess its only fair to disclose that yes, am an IIM C alumni, albeit a hurt one.

    Best wishes,

  20. I would say point of view matters.
    Would be really interested to know Ma'am if you actually decide to go to an institute because it has better infra.And as far as usage of pictures is concerned, I would say that
    should give the readers another biased view of the IIM C campus, which is my second most favourite one, the first being my alma mater.

    didnt really want to post this comment, but in light of the fact that a lot of aspirants read ur blog, felt the need to provide another pictographic biased view.

  21. Adding to all that has been written already, you do seem to suffer from an IIM-A bias!

    You almost attribute IIM-B's rise to a faculty member who was earlier at IIM-A but fail to mention that the current IIM-C director has also served earlier at IIM-A...

    But then this small fact would have defeated your argument of IIM-A supremacy... right???

  22. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

  23. I am an admirer of your posts and
    always recommend your articles to
    everyone.. so i guess i have earned
    the right to blast this post as almost
    complete drivel.

    "If you dont know Bengali in Kolkata, then you are gone because people dont want to communicate in any other language."

    This is the crappiest part.
    Forget short time visitors.. many many
    marwaris have lived and done business
    in Calcutta for generations .. many
    of them do not speak bengali (though
    many of them do speak). if you can
    sell clothes to retail customers
    (including innerwear) without knowing
    bengali, you gotta admit your statement is way off.

  24. After spending the better part of two years at IIM-C, the thing which scares me most about the place is the fierceness exhibited by IIM-C students (wise beyond their "y'ears'"!). They jump to its defence with a clannish fervour every time someone makes the smallest comment about the place. For an institute reputed to be "laid-back", this puts paid to THAT myth. Nothing laid-back about screaming oneself hoarse at every opportunity.
    Personally I agree with Rashmi that infra@IIM-C sucks...AND whats more is we're damn right proud of the fact that it sucks! To all the self-proclaimed defenders of the faith @ IIM-C if its true that infra is irrelevant and that HUMAN BONDING and warmth are all it takes then-what stops the Sisters of Charity from starting a world-class management institute to compete with the likes of IIMA or B?? The sooner IIM-C wakes up the better for it.There's a dire need to upgrade and revamp EVERY aspect of its infrastructure (physical AND otherwise) if its to realize its inflated ambitions. I have OFTEN wondered why it is that there aren't many many more NON-BENGALI faculty to teach here? Now I think its becoz they
    simply couldnt take it any more!! What is it about the Bengali mindset that makes it sooo resistant to every new idea??!! Surely EVERYTHING cannot be wept under the carpet of CONSERVATISM?!
    Everywhere the law of survival of the fittest will take its toll; IIM-C need not consider itself any exception to the rule-no matter what the Bhadralok are disposed to imagine.
    The points raised by Rashmi are VALID.I don't like to go outside my room and see my neighbour's underwear drying in the hot Calcutta sun! Let him dry it on his ceiling fan if he has to goddammit!
    Rashmi is only comparing us with IIM-A and IIM-B.From the furore this has generated on campus and outside, one would imagine that the heavens would fall if Someone were to compare IIM-C with say a HARVARD or STANFORD! Now wouldnt that really hurt?!
    What IIM-C needs most now is a reality check and shock therapy-Resting on laurels of the past will only serve to take it down the path of the Dinosaurs.Sometimes I despair if even the ARMY can change things at IIM-C!
    All its verdant beauty conceals the brutal fact that this institute is terminally ill, caught in the vicious suffocating coils of bureaucratic lethargy and official apathy that--even as I write this-- is stifling the so-called "creativity" right out to Kingdom Come.

  25. What a waste of blogging webspace and internet bandwidth is this!?!?!? If you have to compare places with a one day walk at one and a two yr stay in another, do in your own little pink diary!

  26. CAM with dragonfire :))

  27. So an intimidating campus(whatever that maybe), few fridges and washing machines, a strict attendance rule and faculty with 10% ceiling on bongs a great B school maketh? Well thats simple really...

    And what about middle class structures? Of course Mahatma Gandhi, APJ abul Kalam, Satyen Bose, CV Raman, Sachin Tendulkar, CNR Rao, Amartya Sen, Lata Mangeshkar had presidential suites for home, thats why they are successful.

    Of course widespread riots, the worst in Indian history, a burned down train and its repurcussions...maketh the breeding ground of towering intellectuals.

    CAM with Rashmi on all counts

  28. SO many ponits already made. Just one more. So tell me how do you compare 90% attendence in 1st and laid back totally in 2nd year is good and 75% attendence in 1st as well 2nd?? How can you asy one is better and other is not?

    And what more can I say, afterthe following comment..

    If you have to compare places with a one day walk at one and a two yr stay in another.............

  29. Its a bit awkward to comment on a blog. After all blogs are opinion pieces and you can have any opinion, even if it is erroneous. Its none of my business.

    But the popularity of your blog is what prompts me to post some sort of a rebuttal.

    From the reading of your blog, the points that I can see mentioned are:

    1.The city is grimy, laidback and not at all dynamic like Abad or Bangalore.
    - Laidback I can agree with, but grimy and "experience" is part of any city. After facing Bangalore traffic you don’t have an experience, you have a rebirth.

    2. IIMC has a very resort like campus.
    - Thanks. We are about to re-build a Beautiful Jetty. This calm atmosphere is what helps us avoid that stressful and harried look that other MBA students always seem to have. After all brick walls are not exactly known for soothing people.

    3. ...viewed the Louis Kahn plaza. I felt awe. I felt humble, insignificant.
    - Interesting point. This, I think, is a key difference. I never felt intimidated or insignificant or "being unworthy of" in IIMC. But then different institutes have different ways of inspiring people. Some do it with fears "better attend classes or else ....", some do it with support "enjoy yourself while you learn".

    3. IIMC Programs are not tough. While A and B really put their students through a grinder.
    - Being put through forced, stressful labour is enjoyed more by a masochistic bent of mind. Even so, the amount of work that is part of curriculum in IIMC, the range of courses and projects that we do is nothing to scoff at. Its a talent to not appear stressed out even when you are being overworked. 75% attendance vs. 90% attendance: college level independence vs. school level guidance and control.

    4. Business magazine rankings
    - Very controversial. You might want to check Recruiter’s perception rankings. After all placements are supposed to be the most important thing.

    5. Sense of movement, new ideas, initiatives
    - You have to be here to know about that. I really don’t know how much you know about IIMC but it seems to be based on a one day visit which does not do justice.

    6. Faculty being 90% bong.
    - So what is the point?

    7. Infrastructure not up to the mark
    - True. At the moment, we are not where we would like to be. But I think the importance of big red brick buildings is a tad overstated in determining the student or the institute quality.

    Overall, it was a controversial blog piece which elicited a lot of response. But I am sure this was neither unexpected nor unwelcome.

    I think you are trolling.

  30. Hi Rashmi,

    I do not mean to demean you but you blog has put me under serious doubts that whether or not you remember anything that they tought at IIMA. We generally remeber things that haunt us not those which make us happy. I see that you are still haunted by IIMA's buildings and the survival series, Even after having survived them.

    I could not see any link between the presence of Heritage buildings in a city and the future of a Management Institute situated at its fringes. Neither could I see the link between the laid back attitude of a city, the ethnic origin of an Institute's professors and the managing capability of the students passing of this place. You are assuming that the moment people land up at IIMC they are transformed into sleepy, useless individuals who do nothing but slumber in dingy rooms with their undies hanging outside. Even if that was true they would be transformed once again. almost as intantaneously when they join the industry.

    Your skills at finding correlations makes me feel relieved that you did not become a stock trader, else your abilty to draw conclusions from what is visible on the surface would have led you to great trouble. How else can you explain a blog on the future of one of the premier Management Institutes of the country from a mere visit of a few hours. Most of us did not even know that you were on campus. Such a series of irresponsible behaviour from such a senior alumnus of the IIMs makes me feel sick.

  31. do u really think that whether there are banians hanging on the corridor or designer suits make any difference to the qulity of a b-school.

    and about the architecture i believe that a building which makes you feel humble and insignificant is just achieving the opposite of what should be intended in a place of learning (remember Stoddard Temple in The Fountainhead)

    if u really wanted to compare iima, b or c u should have done that using more serious parameters like placements, number of papers published etc.

    (just for clarification - im not an iimc student)

  32. Rashmi,

    I follow your blogs with interest. However, I am sorry to say that this one is not up to the expectations.

    I invested 2 of my best years in one of the great IIMs and worked for quite a bit after that around the globe. I am surprised to see that even rational folks like you get in worthless discussion of "what is the pecking order of the IIMs".

    Do you actually believe that this ranking makes any sense OR every single student of IIM A is better manager in the long run than every student of IIM I or K (leave C or B for the timebeing) just because IIM A is supposed to be a better IIM?

    I have the privilege of being friends and colleagues of all IIMs alumni and its impossible to tell a quality of a manager by his institute. The reason is that in this mad rush of count-down we forget that the most important factor of success in anyone's life is not whether one had fridge in the dorm or AC in the classroom or whether the faculty was international but the attitude and the determination to succeed.

    Agreed that the institution has a role to play but it is very limited in one's success. The selection criteria for IIMs are so tough that anyone who is in is bound to be a decent success in life.

    There have been spectacular failures from IIM A and great successes from other institutes and vice versa.

    The whole debate of the rankings of IIMs is a worthless exercise. It has all to do with sensationalism and nothing to do with reality. Each of the IIMs (the young L, I and K will catch in due course of time) are great institutes.

    If this blog is to excite your magazine audience (which I guess are 16-20 yr old, no work experience, fresh out of college, countdown watching crowd), then you are successful in getting some more sales. But as a responsible editor and educated person I hope you avoid sensationalism and portray the correct picture that all IIMs are great places. What ones become after IIM is solely dependent on how much effort one puts into the course and more importantly later on.

    Its a well established fact that the recruiter-list for placements in IIM A, B and C are almost identical. The top recruiters hire almost the same number of guys from each campus. Its never a case that a mediocre student in IIM A gets a better job than a top student of IIM B/C. The job distribution across the quality of students in these three IIMs are almost identical.

    I thought that you are following your passion of talking to youth and giving them some direction and hence you had chosen a not-so-beaten path. However, seeing this meaningless article makes me wonder whether you are also out there to sell your magazine "JAM" by any means.

    I am saddened by this fall in standards in your writing.

  33. Way to go, Rashmi!

    Of course, buildings matter! Take a lot at the stiff competition that goes on in US campuses. To give an example, my former school, (Haas, Berkeley)has remodelled its campus to pursue its goal of being in the top 5 B-schools in the world.

    Of course, diversity in faculty matters. Once again, Haas has had the distinction of attracting a diverse international pool of academics - from Nobel Prize winners, to top govt officials to big time entrepreneurs and executives. Diversty in the student pool matters too. I found it an eye opening experience to intereact with extremely bright and articulate people from all walks of life and not just from the IT sector.

    Rashmi clearly has pride in these institutions and wants them to be world class. Her post was a nudge in the right direction. Clearly, if you want to attract a certain profile of students and faculty, you have to *look* and *act* world-class and here, and rankings matter!

    Harvard, Stanford, Berkeley are recognized brands the world over. Yet, their deans are constantly thinking of ways to innovate teaching methods, rip apart campuses, raise funds, fund research and bring about real change in industry and society. In fact, alumni keep getting emails and snail mails from the deans of these schools.

    Something we Indians can learn from them, no?

  34. Okay, to begin with, you're missing IIM C's biggest advantage over WIMWI - W. Bengal is NOT a dry state. You can actually get beer on the IIM C campus! BEER (sob!). And if you want something harder, you get to CHOOSE - you don't just gratefully accept whatever moonshine your local bootlegger manages to arrange. That alone should be enough to convince any right thinking person to go to C. :-).

    Seriously, though, I do think you're being unfair to Cal. I'm never averse to articles that laud the old alma mater, but even I'm forced to admit that the arguments you make here for its superiority over Cal barely hold water. I mean, okay, so I definitely agree that Ahmedabad has better architecture. But I don't know about anything else.

    1) When I visited Cal in 2001 my sense was that the hostels were better, not worse - certainly Net connectivity from hostel rooms was superior at the time (though I suspect it's about the same now), and rooms were a little smaller, but otherwise amenities were more or less equivalent.

    2) Calcutta, your friend says, is dead and oppressive. Compared to what, Ahmedabad? Which features half a decent movie hall, no theatre to speak of, and a half dozen genuine restaurants? Really?

    3) While I'm all for diversity of faculty - I'm not sure that Bong vs. otherwise is the relevant dimension to judge diversity on. Surely where they got their PhDs from, or what disciplines they're trained in would be more useful?

    4) Let's leave arguments that imply that spending more time in classrooms equals greater learning or a more rigorous program to the Ponytails of the world, shall we? Nothing I've seen or heard on Cal campus or experienced in years of working with IIM Cal graduates suggests to me that the Cal program is any less analytical or rigorous than the program at Ahmedabad. They may spend less time in the classroom, but that doesn't mean they're less competitive. And frankly, I can think of plenty of courses I took at A where I would have been much better off attending only 70% of classes. If only.

    I do agree, though, that IIM C could do a better PR job - so to the extent that you're saying it's an undervalued institute I'm entirely with you.

    Bottomline: I've worked with a number of IIM Cal alumni over the years; some of them are close friends of mine. And I've never had anything but respect for their ability, attitude or talent. My assumption has therefore always been that IIM C is, in every objective way, as good a business school as Ahmedabad. So if it's genuinely true, as you would have us believe, that the infrastructure is worse, the faculty less competent and the course work less challenging and dynamic, then I can only conclude (reluctantly) that their students must be smarter than ours - just to compensate. But we're not really going to believe that, are we?

  35. Been to neither, but odd to see adults behaving like kids....Interesting.
    As long as the finished product is good what else matters??
    Atleast it probably leaves the IIMC ians hardier and little more down to earth than the IIMA ians with no offence to other IIMA ians.

  36. IIMs are so overhyped that ppl are not even ready to acknowledge the lack of adequate infrastructure. Someone commented on what difference would infra have for a potential B School aspirant. Well wait for another 5 -8 years when many top universities around the world come and establish their campuses ! Do you guys think they would provide the same facilities you have @ IIM- C ?

    Why only look at the infra . i think all the IIMs should dig depper into their dens and answer some basic questions like : In its so many years of existence why hasn't IIMs produced more than a handful of world class leaders as yet. Why are only most of the CEOs hailing from the Harvards, and Whartons of the world ? i guess something is terribly wrong with the system. Having said that I must accept the fact that most of the students who get into any IIM are very intelligent. But once they enter an IIM for most of them as someone rightly put it is a case of " I was born intelligent but education ruined me . "

    If you just wander around a few B Schools , have a peek into the hostel rooms you would have perhaps derived a new meaning for "world class infrastructure ".

    I live in Mumbai and if you have some spare time while moving around the fort area use the male rest room @ JBIMS . And you would understand what I mean.

  37. Just wanted to say WOW- people really DID jump down your throat on this one - maybe you made some snap judgements, maybe you didn't, but I just wanted to say that you're entitled to your opinion and that people who post here telling you to "NOT write things like this" obviously have some issues with the freedom of speech..easy now folks, this IS her blog, it's what SHE thinks! it doesn't necessarily make it true or set in stone!

  38. hey rashmi abt th IIM-A intimidating part.......i was at IIM-A for my GD/PI and i think the building was so intimidating that it was not inviting....
    also i think abt the laid back attitude and 75% attendence....i think that is much better than breathing down someones back.......that tooo at the PG level!These people are not junior college students....

    Also i do understand this is you personal opinion...but i did not like this post.Its not just IIM-c you should not compare any college to another.....werent you the one who said the the B-schools must concentrate less on the rankings and solve the real problem?!

    im really disappointed in this one...

  39. dear rashmi,

    i am a regular reader of your blog, and well, i wouldn't repeat other commenters in saying that u dissapointed me in this blog. You are entitled to your point of view that "my b school is better than yours", because inspite of your saying it, this is what your post sounded like.

    You compared IIM A and IIM C on basis of the regional attributes of faculty, not their achievements, you compared the two on the basis which was more "laidback", on percentage of attendence required, on how "middle class" and "marxist" the living quarters were. The point remains is what should be the priority of these factors when comparing b schools.

    You said that IIM A's breathtaking architecture out shines IIM C's.

    Would you really say these are not trivial points of comparison.

    If someone were to compare Harvard or Sloan with IIM A, would they be comparing them on these factors to say which is better?

    I would request you not to call this a proper comparison and the reasons IIM C went wrong, but a totally personal account of why you though your life was better because you were in IIM A. I guess you got a little mixed up.


    ps- i am not a student from any of the iim-s

  40. I think its just a publicity stunt by rashmi to get traffic for her blogspot. Such a post is sure to bring in hits especially from the b-schoolers

    So is this a kind of brand building / awareness exercise for your blogspot eh...??

  41. Piush,

    I think we have all the rights to criticize the post but to start levelling frivolous charges makes it all look really childish. she has a right to express her opinions and we readers can retort to the 'post' but let's not accuse her of writing it for publicity.
    Rashmi, we might not agree on some posts but we love your blog. period.


  42. Rashmi,

    Am an IIMCian but from a millenia ago (95) and haven't been to campus in some time (In fact, I have been given to believe that campus has vastly improved since we were there!).

    Your observations about the campus buildings and whatnot all seem to be pretty accurate - I guess to an outsider IIMC must look pretty rundown. Am glad to see you agree on the lakes though - absolutely fantastic aren't they?

    Even in the Dark Ages when dinosaurs roamed the earth (mixed temporal perspectives I know!) and we were students at IIMC the infrastructure was pretty good. The comp infrastructure was good and the library was great. The faculty were good (not all, frankly) and there were some outstanding courses that students attended, compulsory attendance or not. And of course, there were a great set of students.

    We could have done things better of course. Not all of our courses were good and there could have been more innovative pedagogy in some areas etc. But I think that's a general complaint with all Indian b-schools, not just IIMC. Also I don't think IIMCs PR has been particularly fantastic, so that is a definite area for improvement.

    Finally, as Falstaff has so fairly pointed out, I didn't see much of a difference b/w IIMA and IIMC (and come to think of it IIMB/L too) in terms of the student quality or job performance in the many companies I worked in or had close friends at. And this, sadly, despite my most fervent, burning, all-encompassing desire as a hardcorely loyal IIMCian to bring to the rest of the world the Divine Truth as I knew It: That IIMCians Did It Better! ;)


  43. er. and rashmi..I'm sure its a typo but shouldn't it be "junta's underwear...?" I thought underwear didn't have a plural form.


  44. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

  45. Rashmi,..i follow your blog regularly and sometimes i have to admit that a bit of IIMAish arrogance creeps into your writings. Architecture wise and campus wise, IIMB has been hailed as being the best, and i'm saying this not because i'm an alumni. and having lived calcutta, yes...everything about calcutta has "soul" and i will never understand why people don't like calcutta as a city.

  46. sorry ali...i agree with piush this is nothing but a publicity stunt......a good effort to increase traffic at your site and the results are here to see......and seriously the blog is as good as a New Yorker going to London for a day and saying it is the worst place around coz london's buildings are old and not as big as New York.....grow up!!

  47. Great Blog Rashmi!!
    As expected you have some very strong reactions.
    However i hoped to see balanced view on this issue. IIMC has few competitive advantages, like Alumni network which is so well reinforced with the online tool and placement relationships with the recruiters. But this advantage like any will fade in some years, and that is where innovations will form a base for the future, exactly where i see IIMC faltering. As i gather from a few responses that the move is on to address all/few issues, but we do not see things happening. The proof of the attitude of IIMC junta is for everyone to see, i hoped IIMC guys would take this blog in the right spirit, and take this criticism as a direction to work on. No criticism can rob IIMC of the great legacy and the illustrious students but the question raised in the blog, which by no means is a well researched report, is whether IIMC can keep the flag flying high, higher than all other flags in comming future?
    The indicators in the blog might be basic but they still are IIMC junta takes it is the whole point.

  48. If your whole point is that the relaxed-image and the chillout kind of perception IIMC portrays to the outside world is the core of the problem of its relative brand image tumbling, I guess it didn't come across.

    What comes across is that you consider IIMA as the model institution and the de facto standard, and that you don't like the city (Calcutta) or the IIMC hostel rooms and infra surrounding it.

  49. Have to agree with Govar on this one. To a completely neutral reader having cast aside any traces of bias, that is to ME, this article still sadly faintly reeks of benchmarking and comparison.

    Looking beyond the obvious, and concentrating on reading between the lines. You do actually raise very valid points which go beyond the rooms/infra/underwear, the fact that IIM-C needs to stand up and be noticed is very very true. It is also true that all of this has to happen in order to fight in the global scenario ....and all the other issues you've raised.

    Your call for IIMC to get up and get going unfortunately may not be heard. Its lost in the trivialities, and the trivialities are what most readers are going to notice. After the 2nd para itself, I knew all I had to do was open the Comments link to face a nice debate. :) 'tis exactly what I got.


  50. Since everybody has said just about everything else, let me add just that wee bit that has been left unsaid (I am a Joka alum). Yeah, you're probably right about the infrastructure and all (haven't visited the campus in two decades) but ...

    - ganja was available right outside the campus gate from Kishanda

    - we had the pleasure of taking our female compatriots for boat rides (that was stopped, I learned, after a couple of students drowned)

    - we had the pleasure of taking Rekha (student) out for a walk around the lake. This was a required duty of all male students in our batch.

    - we got to eat mishthi dohi at Sri Durga's in Behala, just opposite the tram depot (do they still have trams?)

    - we got to drink the famous Jupiter 21 beer

    - we got to listen to lectures by phamous, eminent, Marxist economists (remember, we were young, idealistic, and hence Marxist then)

    - we lived too far away from town to get into much trouble

    - the famous Bengali Puja festival; 'nuf said

    - we got to rescue villagers during a huge downpour, when the entire region (including our campus) turned into monstrous inland sea.

    - we learned why Marxism and socialism are pretty lousy ideas; unlike numerous Indian professional Leftist "intellectuals" who study and work in places like JNU and run "NGOs", two years in Kolkata will cure you of this disease forever

    To cut short this already overlong story, you're right about a lot of what you're saying, but ... no Indian campus will ever compare with even the lowliest campus in the US, so what are we arguing about? Harvard is phamous not for its instruction or facilities(you can get as good instruction at US business school #20 for one-tenth the money) but for its "connections". You can ignore pretty much everything you learn at Harvard and yet succeed. CAT selects people who are smart and motivated enough -- it is just a filter. They will probably do just as well even if they spent two years inside a coal mine.

    Sure, I think IIM-C should improve its campus. So should IIM-B and IIM-A and all the 23 other alphabets. (BTW - I have spent a couple of terms teaching at IIM-B: the sarkari bureaucracy there including peons, is nauseating. Likewise at IIM-C.) None of this is likely to greatly impact how the alums perform later in life.

    Just my 88-odd paise.


  51. Rashmi ..Please come out of this IIMania.. :-))

    write something else...

  52. Amen to Ali. As Voltaire put it (or I think he put it) - "Dude I dunno what you say, but I defend to kingdom come ya right to say it". I'm not from any of the IIMs, being a humble CA (and God knows what a complete bunch of bores we are), but I am a fan of this site. Vot publicity yaar ! I mean come on - this is a blog !! - its OPINION !!

  53. I can agree that Joka doesnt have the best infrastructure, but wonder how does that reflect in the capabilities of the people who graduate from there.

    Are we talking about MBAs who think that the degree gives them the luxury of a AC dorm forever and cannot stay in other conditions?

    And if red bricks determined how good an institution was - I guess all educational facilities would be red. And talking of being awe-struck by the campus, am sure an alma mater is something special. Dont think you would ever get the same feeling at any other place.

    Have been a regular reader of your posts, but even in a very unbiased way, I am not sure what were trying to indicate by that post.


  54. Well, i suppose the marxist thoughts do flow over. After all , how long can a capitalist establishment remain without being affected by the unreasonable marxist crap being talked outside the gates. The apathy has to carry over. Its not the IIM, Kolkata itself has that image of laidbackness, pointless arguments, apathy and gloom. 20 years of Marxism , nay more of Maoism rather than Marxism.

    God Bless IIMC. In fact, I hope all IIMS do well. Wish you success. (disclaimer: i am not an IIMian, in fact not an MBA at all)

  55. Hey Rashmi,

    Success is yours! Traffic is up; you have suddenly changed your image from a somewhat treacly do-gooder to a controversial Christopher Hitchens-type provocateur; and basically spiced up your blog with this post. :)

    Way to go, spice-lady!

  56. Guess if you had presented a 'neutral' visitor's perspective on IIM, it would have been more bloggish rather than sloggish, so to speak. Passing judgments based on hanging underwears, small rooms, homogeneous faculty is a bit too harsh. Hence this outburst. Treating (and enjoying) any new place as an absolute might be a better idea.
    As a sidenote, modernisation of infrastructure wont necessarily mean un-underwearisation of hostel corridors :)

  57. --- Now Kolkata as a city is the next hot thing, and the general mood among people and administrators of the state/city is quite similar to what would have been in Bangalore 7-8 years ago. So the only way it can go is up.

    Is it so. kolkota ?? Next Hot thing ?!? .. I am surprised. Whatever industry was there in the earlier days, has been driven out by cpm terrorists on the streets calling bandh every alternate day.
    Bengal can never progress as long as your cpm maoists are around.

  58. Rashmi,
    I thought ur blog was ridiculous...U r no "neutral" observer miss, out and out crazy IIMA fanatic!
    I have been to IIMA and didnt see any ACs in the rooms nor huge bedrooms to offer convenience to its pupils.
    Just one thing to say: If ur so-called "understanding" of IIMC is true, how come IIMC lands up with jobs as good as(sometimes better) IIMA? Guess IIMC even with its "laidback" attitude "bad" attendence rules performs ATLEAST as well as an IIMA....

  59. does IIMA have more females than IIMC?
    bottomline: they both suck! :)
    its only the toppers that get the gals! what about the rest of the junta??!?!?!

  60. Yet another disappointing one from you Rashmi. Not worth the space it is eating both for the post and the reactions.

    I remember you writing some time back that you regret not writing enough. If writing this kind of posts is what you call writing enough - then you were better off writing less.

    I tend to agree with what kidinutopia, piush and Govar has commented about this post.

  61. Am I the only guy here who thinks some of the things being said in the comments are ridiculous!

    First of all...I have neither attended nor been to any of the IIM's so my opinion is out of the question.

    But I do find the attitude of some of the commenters absurd.
    On a large scale people seem to be pissed that 'this post hasnt lived up to the standards'. Ok...maybe true but I dont think she has any obligation to outdo herself everytime. This is her blog goddamitt...she can write anything she wants and I feel noone has any right to expect something and then flame her personally for not living upto those.
    As a responsible editor for JAM she has a responsibilty to provide unbiased opinions...IN THE MAGAZINE. Why shud she in her personal space? None of you are paying for the 'bandwidth/netspace' she is taking up. So stop cribbing that 'this post doesnt deserve its resources used'. God...that has to be the stupidest thing anyone has ever said.

    And the most ridiculous accusation is the one related to Rashmi trying increase her blog-popularity through her posts. Something like this doesnt even deserve a rebuttal.

    So a lot of you are pissed at her for making unfair comparison. From her post and from some of the more sensible comments I guess she probably was being unfair. But for godssake stop this righteousness facade and criticize her in a healthy way.

  62. I totally agree with Roman about the largely partisan nature of the comments made. Most of them are by the peeved IIM-C junta as is this one. But my hope is to let this one be DIFFERENT! I'd like to reiterate for the benefit of my irate colleagues from IIM-C that its usually considered good form to light a candle rather than to curse someone for reminidng us of the darkness that prevails. Nowhere is the laid-back approach visible. So what if she's wrong? Why not let her say WHATEVER SHE WANTS! Why not act and prove her wrong? But NO!- that would be sacrilege as the clan recognizes that its HONOUR is at stake. What honour? Are we talking about the Northwest Frontier Province or is this a B-school with an eye on being the world's best?!!
    For those who need it this is a reminder that the "Honour" of IIM-C is simply the legacy of past generations that did their duty when it mattered and kept silent when others weren't; its NOT the result of them shouting hoarse over every provocation. But of course the example of past generations is consigned to the archives of the Administrative Block, decorated with the reddest of red tape!
    Before the junta from IIM-C vilify Rashmi and/or other hapless unfortunates (myself included!) that happen to stoke their world-renowned formidable passions, it might be better for them to start by putting their own home-also MY home--in ORDER, FIRST AND FOREMOST.Faint hope of THAT happening, for one does not expect reason from a MOB.
    IIM-C will also do well to remember that "A HOUSE DIVIDED AGAINST ITSELF CANNOT STAND".I do not expect that IIM-C can endure permanently with one foot firmly planted in the Dark Ages and another in the New Millennium. (This after all is why this institute so successfully manages to PISS ON ITS PRESENT )
    One does not need to trouble comparing IIM-C with Harvard and/or the other eminent Ivy League worthies...Any third or fourth rung American university would put IIM-C to shame in terms of infra alone, and I think I can safely say that. Its not for want of funds either! IIM-C sits on a huge corpus (120 crores was what I heard last--one wouldn't suspect it from where I'm sitting now!)
    And before the mob here start screaming themselves hoarse about this comparison with a third tier US B-school,(and accuse me of Scrolling/Trolling or whatever else!) I'd like to remind them that its just THAT --the MOB MENTALITY-- which is the bane of the institute's existence today.That along with the apathy from officialdom and the sheer complacency of being rated so highly by all and sundry will be the bane of IIM-C's attempts to project itself as the friendly neighbourhood B-school of the future.

  63. rashmi

    just one line of comment to add

    I have been to IIM A, was also selected in IIM A but had joined IIM C and I dont have one line of repentence


  64. I totally agree with Roman about the largely partisan nature of the comments made. Most of them are by the peeved IIM-C junta as is this one. But my hope is to let this one be DIFFERENT! I'd like to reiterate for the benefit of my irate colleagues from IIM-C that its usually considered good form to light a candle rather than to curse someone for reminidng us of the darkness that prevails. Nowhere is the laid-back approach visible. So what if she's wrong? Why not let her say WHATEVER SHE WANTS! Why not act and prove her wrong? But NO!- that would be sacrilege as the clan recognizes that its HONOUR is at stake. What honour? Are we talking about the Northwest Frontier Province or is this a B-school with an eye on being the world's best?!!
    For those who need it this is a reminder that the "Honour" of IIM-C is simply the legacy of past generations that did their duty when it mattered and kept silent when others weren't; its NOT the result of them shouting hoarse over every provocation. But of course the example of past generations is consigned to the archives of the Administrative Block, decorated with the reddest of red tape!
    Before the junta from IIM-C vilify Rashmi and/or other hapless unfortunates (myself included!) that happen to stoke their world-renowned formidable passions, it might be better for them to start by putting their own home-also MY home--in ORDER, FIRST AND FOREMOST.Faint hope of THAT happening, for one does not expect reason from a MOB.
    IIM-C will also do well to remember that "A HOUSE DIVIDED AGAINST ITSELF CANNOT STAND".I do not expect that IIM-C can endure permanently with one foot firmly planted in the Dark Ages and another in the New Millennium. (This after all is why this institute so successfully manages to PISS ON ITS PRESENT )
    One does not need to trouble comparing IIM-C with Harvard and/or the other eminent Ivy League worthies...Any third or fourth rung American university would put IIM-C to shame in terms of infra alone, and I think I can safely say that. Its not for want of funds either! IIM-C sits on a huge corpus (120 crores was what I heard last--one wouldn't suspect it from where I'm sitting now!)
    And before the mob here start screaming themselves hoarse about this comparison with a third tier US B-school,(and accuse me of Scrolling/Trolling or whatever else!) I'd like to remind them that its just THAT --the MOB MENTALITY-- which is the bane of the institute's existence today.That along with the apathy from officialdom and the sheer complacency of being rated so highly by all and sundry will be the bane of IIM-C's attempts to project itself as the friendly neighbourhood B-school of the future.

  65. The point of whether Rashmi's article is biased or not - its quite irrelevant. All that is relevant is whether much of what is mentioned is true or not.

    Its so easy to dismiss it as an opinion of an exIIMA - but the point is for a common man /aspiring student/overseas corporate recruiters, its going to look much worse - because they have much higher expections from the campus that Rashmi would anyway.

    Its really sad to see IIMCians being in this state of denial !!

  66. Well if Rashmi's comments help highlight certain shortcomings of IIM-C no harm.I just hope this was well meant and not an attempt to tarnish the reputation of C.And it is very very difficult to characterise people from each place in only so many words as Rashmi and some others attempted.Every place has its creative geniuses and laidbacks.We are all human at the end of it are we not ?
    And no matter where you go your basic nature can change only so much so let us not stereotype people so casually.We can have better discussions also.Why do we not talk about good things at all schools ? We want all the IIMs to become world class and let us combine the so called "special" ness of IIM-C with the "PR" of IIM-A and the "grind" of IIM-B !!!

  67. Totally agree with Murli on the Filtering part. I too believe that a lot of what comes out of IIM A,B,C is due to what goes in - rather than the "process". Sure the hostels at Joka leave a lot to be desired. I lived in one of those rooms with the picturesque undies right outside for 2 years- do I regret it - hell no. I was thankful that there was a Dhobi to wash clothes though. And the lake I could look at when I wasn't looking at the undies wasn't too bad either.

    Personally I thought the hostels at Joka were much better than those at IIT-M. When I just joined IIT M (98)- there was a water problem in Chennai. The loos didn't have working flushes which worked and if you started your day without encountering fixed deposits, you considered yourself lucky.
    IIM C was by that note - much better. For any darned moment does that take anything away from IIT-M students? Hell no. Does IIM C infra suck- yes.
    Does it take away from IIM C students- no..Does it suck as much as it is made out by the pics and this post-probably not.
    Calcutta might be laid back. IIM C admin might suck. But IIM C is what is is, despite these, not because of these.
    Infra and sad profs are a common complaint across IIMs. My friends from IIM A and B have mentioned profs who are amazing and some who are atrocious. IIM C has its share. We do have some amazing profs too, both bong and non bong.
    I agree IIM C infra surely needs to improve though - but on the red bricks part- I haven't seen or been awed by them But well, I'll settle for the Joka lakes, the jetty, the Howrah bridge, and if you dont agree - may the birds poop on you :)

    Cynical Side notes: From what I've seen, people usually pick A over B and C.
    Between B and C people pick based on geographical proximity to home/boyfriend/girlfriend/other soft reasons. A lesser number of people pick C or B over A for the same reasons. The more fun loving people might pick C or B because of
    - no (now lesser/less strict) attendance -c
    - i love bangalore -b
    - bong factor -c
    - my friends are going to either - b/c
    - iit kgp -> c

    And that I think is the way it should be - because I believe there is little to choose between them.

    So all these debates mostly result in a lot of time pass. Continuing on the filtering theme - Last year, A leading recruiter (yes!it was a bank!) was heard saying "We need people who can do some math and can communicate well. The rest- we can teach them."

    So long as intelligent people clear cat and go to the IIMs, recruiters will continue to go there in hordes cos the average quality of talent here is higher than elsewhere- red bricks, Kahn architecture, Lakes and bird poo notwithstanding.


  68. One major factor to not go to IIMA - No alcoholic drinks available. You have to get the stuff illegally at a premium

  69. People who choose B-schools on alcoholic considerations are probably better off getting sozzled at the local pub or bar. Without pointing fingers, its when drunks get into B-schools that you wind up with Damagers instead of Managers.

  70. Very, very interesting debate, at least to a non-IIM alumnus outsider like me. Rashmi, with regard to your piece, my observations are:

    I'm sorry to say, but I don't share your enthusiasm for the IIMA building. I don't care much for Louis Kahn as an architect, especially that monstrosity he designed as the Dhaka Parliament. The IIMA building is no different, and is very austere and uninviting. Give me a socialist type office-block any day that doesn't masquerade as great architecture.

    The attendance thing is redundant at the level of postgraduate studies. Anyone motivated enough to get into an IIM can take care of his/her own classes.

    Diversity is great, but I don't know how useful it is if all faculty members are Indians who've passed through the same national education system. As Arun says, it does count for a lot in a place like Haas, because the faculty and student body is truly international. This is certainly not the case for any of the IIMs.

    I just checked the US B-school rankings and they have Harvard in first place, almost neck-to-neck with Stanford and Wharton. Now if I was choosing between them, I would invariably choose Stanford. Why? Heck which moron would drop gorgeous Palo Alto to go freeze their ass in Cambridge, Mass. Maybe folks are choosing IIMC for the liquor after all :).

  71. well said smartca

    alcohol is bad for managers

    so quit alcohol if u want to be a good manager

    thank u smartca that was your contribution to the 8th habit to become an effective manager(stephen covey must be smiling)

  72. I feel this lady doesn't talk in thin air. She has facts to support whatever she says, but in this case, she is biased. Very biased.

    I agree with you on what you say about IIM-C but do not agree on what you say should IIM-C be like.

    I didn't go to any of the IIMs, yet I know for sure that people who make it to these IIMs are pretty much the same (engineers, IITians, academically brilliant, some hardworking, some laidback)

  73. Just for Curiosity's sake...

    Where EXACTLY does IIMA junta dry its underwear?!

  74. about Indian's absolute inability to consider another point of view.
    Remember that Rashmi is in the magazine industry, and seems to understand much better than most of the commentators on her blog, that perception matters, in fact it is everything. Whether she believes newspaper rankings are an accurate portrayal of actual quality, is irrelevant. What is important, as Rashmi mentions, is that those ratings actually influence good students' choice of a B school. She gives her opinion on why she believes the magazines' perceptions of IIM-C have dropped, and all you guys can do is bash it. It is okay to disagree, but most opinions come across as Knee jerk reactions, rather than considered thoughts.

    Her points,
    1) The awe inspiring look that the campus lacks. You have to have lived near a building that is inspirational to realize the effect architecture has on a human. But that is besides the point, fact is, many aspirants might be inspired to go to a college which fills them with grandeur, rather than a college whose atmosphere looks no different from where they spent the last 15 years of their life. Most probably, daring and risk taking people would choose the former alternative. Do note that this will have a very small yet significant influence.

    2) Diversity is essential. Every man is the sum of his experiences, and people from similar geographical and cultural backgrounds tend to have similar thinking. 90% of the faculty being of any single group (whether Bong, Jewish, or Konkani) is bad irrespective of the quality of the professors. While it does not hurt the students, it prevents them from acquiring an appreciation for other thoughts, ideas and cultures (a point which seems very well demonstrated by most of the respondents to this post).

    3) Forget comparing IIM-C to A, the fact that an institute that claims to be modern and international, needs its students to dry clothes in their rooms, definitely gives the impression that it does not live up to those claims. Note that I am not saying that it is not a great university, or as modern as you can get, but these clothes do not present that idea, in fact, they give the impression of an ordinary outdated school. Instead of comparing, if you would think about improving your alma mater as best as you can, rather than being satisfied by the status quo, Rashmi's post would surely have looked quite different.

    For the record, I am a 2nd year undergraduate student studying in the USA, having lived in Bombay for all my life before college.

  75. seeing all these comments i am not quite sure who needs a "serious kick in the butt"

  76. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

  77. I very much agree with Kali/Varun...guys wake up and is someone who is talking what she wants in her blog, in her space, and in her time, she has all the rights to do so... Where is freedom of speech gone? Is it just we use it in our defences only during controversies external to blogosphere? Is it not internally applicable too? Why go on an attacking-spree now? Why can't we be sensible enough to just read the blog with an open mind and take the good things and ignore the ones we don't need/care...why to stoop to such low levels of criticisms...It sure defeats the purpose of education big time...

  78. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

  79. Murli: I don't remember seeing any trams around, and I'm afraid I must have missed Rekha on my trip there, but just wanted to say that yes, the mishti doi was truly spectacular. As was the ganja. Though mixing the two proved to be not such a good idea.

    Personally, I think the best indicator of IIM C's lack of proper infrastructure is the lakes. Just look at the lakes that US business schools like Northwestern have. IIM C's lakes are nothing in comparison. It's such a shame. :-).

  80. A person can be judged in more than one way - attire, watch, shades, footwear etc...because, these reflect a person's personality...the same holds good for anything including Institutes...

  81. how the logic of laid back bengali culture is flawed

    take a look at the list of bengali professors in IIM-A

    1. Bandyopadhyay Tathagata -
    Production and Quantitative Methods
    Production and Quantitative Methods
    PhD, University of Calcutta.

    M.Sc (Statistics),University of Calcutta.

    2.Banerjee Arindam
    Marketing Ph.D. (SUNY at Buffalo), PGDM (IIM Lucknow), B.E. (Delhi College of Engg.)

    3.Banerjee Bibek

    Ph.D. in Economics (May 1994)

    Major Field: Industrial Organization

    Supporting Fields: Marketing Science, Economics of Uncertainty

    Krannert Graduate School of Management

    Purdue University, Indiana, U.S.A.

    M.S. in Economics (December 1990)

    Krannert Graduate School of Management

    Purdue University, Indiana,

    B.Sc. (Honors) in Economics (December 1988)

    Minor areas: Mathematics and Statistics

    St. Xavier's College
    University of Calcutta,
    4. Dutta Goutam
    Production and Quantitative Methods
    B.Tech (Hons) -IIT, Kharagpur, 1979

    PGDM, XLRI, Jamshedpur, 1988

    PGDOR, ORSI, Calcutta, 1988

    Ph.D., Northwestern University, 1996.

    5.Ghosh Diptesh

    Production and Quantitative Methods
    Fellow (Operations Research and Systems Analysis) from IIM Calcutta, (graduated in 1998)

    Bachelor of Technology (Mechanical Engg.) from IIT Kharagpur, (graduated in 1992).



    thank point is made

  82. @Kickinthebutt,

    When Rashmi's intentions are not against anyone, why try making it now on your own? I would urge you to read Varun's point # 2 and then tell what you think...It's precisely what Rashmi and a whole lot of us think...

  83. Rashmi’s painstaking efforts should inspire change. Change for better… That is what development communications is all about….

  84. @Graffiti Speak

    Whyare you impinging on kickinthebutt's freedom of speech after making such a strong statement for the same? Its his opinion and he can express i, right?

  85. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

  86. my dear grafitispeak



  87. Just one question Rashmi,
    Why this blog (which still has to establish the link between the"observations" and the effect on student performance) at a time when students are about to make an informed choice? Being in the industry where ur opinion has an accountability, u shud be the last one to makes allegations without evidence...
    ~half truths are more dangerous than lies

  88. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

  89. I can go on and on with my arguments but then I am more aware that there are people in this world who can never be convinced I sign-off here...

  90. @Falstaff, good to know that ganja and mishthi doi are still available in plenty. I fear, however, that our dear pusher-man Kishanda and his equally stoned goat are no more. Circle of life.

    You couldn't have met Rekha at IIMC. She is long gone from there. Two kids, and in the USA.

    Comparing Joka's lakes with something in the US is unfair. In comparison with anything in the US even the famed Louis Kahn structures are going to suffer.

    BTW, the B V Doshi (of Kanvinde and Doshi, student of Le Corbusier of Chandigarh fame) designed IIMB campus looks impressive initially, but try spending some time in those dark, dank, granite interiors. Also, none of the IIMB buildings will pass US safety regulations. Try taking small children upstairs in the library: they are likely to fall from them. You'll need to tie them to table legs or something like that.

    How about this: I am the only guy to have circumnavigated the Joka campus in both directions in a boat. This was when the entire locality (tens of square miles) was under water after a heavy monsoon downpour. This feat can never be repeated. Take that, Northwestern!

    This is Rashmi's blog, and she is sharing her genuine impressions. Par for the course. But she is making her impressions public. She can take the heat too, I guess.

    I visited my undergrad alma mater a few years ago with my son. It was a very painful experience. The only bright spot was my nickname, scribbled in then wet cement in the bathroom, had endured three decades of wear.

    A general upgradation of facilities across the board, all over India is in order. I think a tour of Infosys, Wipro and other such gleaming modern campuses should do much to inspire. On the other hand, civic sense needs to improve across the board among all Indians too. Without this, a gleaming, modern, new campus will quickly die of rot.

  91. Rashmi,
    I agree tht everyone has his/her own opinion abt everything but displaying it in public forum (mind it, ur blogsite is a public forum by now) will obviously create such furore, which i m sure was expected by you.
    I also have lots of opinion abt a lots of things which may be controversial like selection of ganguly/ attitude prob with IIMA alumnus/ winning of Debojit et al, but that does not mean that i will make my outburst on a public forum like this.
    All i can say is that this is the most immature article by an IIM alumnus i have ever read.

  92. To UNdertaker...

    how many blogs of IIMA alumni have u can u make such a generic statement...

    please do ur homework before makin such statements......

    and who are you to judge the immaturity...are u claimin maturity....

    and most of all if she has acted immaturely why do u expect her to react maturely to ur comment...

    all i can say is u have wasted ur time ..

    "This exercise by me is to bring to the notice of you all the MOCKERY of the verification process made by 41st batch placement representatives.

    "Please download the attached Summers and Finals resumes of Sunjit Grover(SEE NOTE#1).
    "Follow the following steps:

    1) Open ‘357_summers.pdf’
    2) Open ‘357_finals.pdf’
    3) Click on ‘Review and Comment’. Click on ‘Show’ and then on ‘Close All Pop-ups’
    4) Place the mouse-pointer over the yellow icons and read on. It was a shocker to me. Some of the points are out and out fraud.

    You think this is the only such “Placerep CV”. Have a look around!!!!! Discrepencies exist in other Placereps’ CVs also. Please get them checked. And it won’t come as a surprise if it is found out that all these points were added by them to their Master CV’s while they were place reps so that the new place reps cannot do anything while verification. Hopefully, the new place reps will support our cause and not let any tampering to be done with the uploaded CVs of the 41st batch place reps.

    "Last year, during 41st batch summers, I have heard that someone’s CV was withdrawn from Slot 0 companies based on a minor mistake he committed. Should not a more severe punishment be meted out to Sunjit Grover. It is a shame that such educated guys resort to these measures and it is time to prove that such type of activities will not be tolerated in future.


    "PS: As you will see, I have not highlighted many points which for a non-placerep would have been impossible to get through the ‘Verification Process’. E.g. He has submitted papers in International Conferences, but nowhere does the word ‘Submitted’ or ‘Authored’ appear in the CV point."

    Note#1: Sunjit Grover- Former s/elected "placement representative" of IIM-Calcutta from 41st batch, now writer of fantasy fiction :D

    Note#2: Ppl who want to see the discrepencies refered above pls can contact:

  94. well rashmi, you are yet another soulless, narrow minded IIMA alumni. I just hate the fact that I am from IIMA too.

  95. Dear Rashmi,
    I am sad to see that you posts these kind of stuffs on blogs. I really do not say that people from IIMA hate other iim guys or vice versa. But it is silly that you really care about neighbours toilet more than yours. Seriously I believe you dont put posts as if you represent IIMA. As you have said .. that institute is definitely bigger than lesser souls like us. Like any other person you should have your role clarified very much before writing these kind of stuff. Is it for creating a debate, are you giving out a research based article, or are your just putting out your perceptions? Any ways you are really good at the first all the best.
    A poor soul from IIMA who believes that all IIMs are really good and what matters is the people inside it.

    Its common across all IIM, and its not IIMC alone. Second thing its unfair to point fingers to SUNJIT GROVER, he had been working as placerep for past one year and even if he doesnot do such a little tampering then whats the use?
    Everyone wish to get the best job and slight tampering is all justified.
    It happens all the time and all placereps and their knowns do, so Mr. Salaam no reason to get angry

  97. I totally agree with u rashmi... i have stayed at campus of C and the infra speaks a lot about itself... the students front there are as bright as (maybe more than) their A,B or any other top-bschool counterparts, but the hostels and the maintainence at the campus sux!!

  98. Rashmi Bansal a lot was said by you in this blog about Infrastructure. Bengali culture, Lower middle class looking hostel rooms, mosquitoes etc.

    What ever you said is based on very little information and that too fairly incorrect but what was your point in saying all this. Who were the target audience?

    If it was just for comparing IIM C with A and B, then I must say it was an extremely narrow minded comparison.
    I believe if you want to compare two different entities, than you should only compare the effectiveness of the outcome from them. Why do you want to see the process? Why do you want to compare on the basis of these factors that are not at all important? Why it is that you want to show some one miniature to prove yourself large?
    If you want to put side by side IIMs than weigh on the basis of student’s profile, placements, academic achievements and how the alumnus of that IIM are being rated in the industry. These are the attributes that a student gains from high profile learning and with over all personality development.

    If it was only to inform the Government or Board of IIM C regarding the “so called falling” Brand image, then also there was no need to put all this in a public forum. You could have prepare a report/ presentation and send it to Ministry of HRD and IIM C Board.
    IIM is a brand name because the word INDIAN associated with it. It not about IIM A, B, C, I, K or L it is only about INDIAN and by posting such blogs you are seriously spoiling brand INDIA.
    A Student while making decision about which IIM to join never considers its location or infrastructure. His only parameter is the value that he could add by joining the institute. If Govt. of India open an IIM in the middle of a “so called backward state” Bihar, student will join that too and companies will come there also because they only trust Brand IIM.

    You said that hostel room looks like lower middle class tiny structure and hostels needs to be demolished. What was your point that a person from lower middle class has no right to study in an IIM or just by entering into IIM you are entitled to live in a Five Star Apartment?
    Do you know that even today more than 25% of Indian population is below poverty line and literacy rate is 64%? When there is such a serious need of fund, why to demolish a structure that is perfectly safe and provide good living conditions to more than 700 students? Why don’t you write something that could help Govt. or other Indians in improving the infrastructure of our country in some way?
    I think these issues are much much bigger than infrastructure of IIM C. But you won’t write about them because from your post it seems like you want cheap publicity.

    Think at least for once about what I have said because no responsible Indian will post such immature thing.

    I believe that as a grad of IIMs our responsibility is to feel every Indian proud on us. I request other readers also to not compare on such parameters. We must only try to enhance the brand equity of IIMs.

  99. I quite agree with a lot of points you've put but as many have stated it still will smell of a bias to any reader (It does atleast to me).
    Why don't you conduct these kinds of IIMA Vs Other management Inst comparisons via an independent person rather than you yourself?
    I have been at neither of the two campuses but if anything you've told for IIM C is true then its time for them to wake up.

  100. Dear Ms Bansal.

    Do you really think that IIM A is IIM A because we have a mini fridge and a washing machine in each dorm? Your post is yet another A vs C post with perhaps content far more trivial than most.

    The entire piece smacks of frivolity - is architecture that intimidates you really the source of IIM A's success?

    In addition to insulting a lot of people from Cal, you're also belittling those of us at Ahmedabad.

    I don't want to get into another debate of which is better. I believe both schools are great and both need quite some work before they become world class.

    I am justly proud of my alma mater. But for things such as the quality of students that come here, the intensity of the course, the brilliant professors. Praising us with great architecture and mosquito free dorms is more insulting than calling us second class!

    - An irritated PGP1@ IIMA

  101. Here lies the Blowed up EGOS of the Managers of Todays India. Right from the incubation, they only see a narrow picture and show BIG VISIONS in their Class and corporate PPTS.

    Instead of bringing all IIMs together to portray them as one strong force for building a nation, people like Rashmi Bansal are hell bent upon dividing them, even though subconsciously.

    Alas, the IIT Days were much better. YES. We still do portray ourselves as one whereve we go. an IITian. Not IIMAite or IIMBian or IIMCian. And down you all go together for having and caring that mentality.

  102. Dear Ms Bansal,
    I'm very qualified to comment on your blog since I'm from an IIM myself and have visited IIMC on more than one occasion.
    I would very well advise you to write about something you really know about instead of slinging mud like you have done here.
    IIMC has liek someone earlier said a "soul",I have met many professors and students and they are BRILLIANT.
    They go way beyond the general curriculum and have proved themselves in other fields as well.
    I doubt if you've heard of an initiative called INCA,or have seen their teamspirit on other occasions.
    When I went for my summers I received help and support from my IIMC friends who otherwise should have been competing with me.This support was academic as well as moral.
    At the end of the day whether I'm from an A,B,C,L,I or K does not matter,what matters is how much I am willing to learn and what kind of a person I become after passing out from my insitute.
    And definitely a red brick building does not change anything,who goes into teh building and who comes out of it does.
    Thanks very much

  103. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

  104. There are a few things I would like to point out.
    The minimum attendance required in IIM A is 80percent.
    Secondly IIM A started a one year program PGP X only after ISB Started and became relatively successful. I m not saying your point does not have merit, just that you seem to come across as being biased.

    Now please don't level accusations of me trying to defend IIM C. Being a 1st year student of IIM A I have absolutely no incentive of doing so. I m just saying please try to get post your views in a more objective manner. The article to me, seemed liked one which had a prejudged result of the comparisions ..rather than evaluating each college on their merits and then giving your judgement.

    Thank you
    Rahul Mamman
    D15-10 IIM A

  105. Congratulions on a wonderful aricle...It seems a fair and objective assesment of the way things have discussed the problems and provided your solutions ...I have no idea that why are people responding in such a manner here...IIM-C is a wonderful institution...the hanging chuddies banians nowithstanding...such things are built for nostalgia and certainly when you have that Ibank job in London ,ul recall those experiences...with a smile on ur face...yes a lot needs to be done on the infrastructure front...and that holds true for most institutions...Overall I am in agreement with Rashmi...I can't really compare the creative aspirations between A & C but I m sure.With due respect to the Bong Intellegensia an overwhelming Bong faculty is not a great idea simply because diversity in the faculty is not only healthy but also has become a USP in most institutions...btw I am not from any IIM-A,B,C,D x y z....or any other..just an observer

  106. Power corrupts...
    Best example.. Rashmi Bansal...
    Editor, JAM Magazine...

    A BIASED Journalist and a management graduate (from a premier institute) is comparing two of the best colleges in India.. on the basis of infrastructure, hostel rooms.. come on give me a break.. lady you are letting your college down by these very smart comparsions..

    How about talking of research, professor profiles, student profiles, placement sceanrio and then saying X is better than Y...

    Yeah and one more thing..
    What about democracy ???

    "At 6:14 PM, IIMC_ROX said...
    This post has been removed by the author."

    An IIM-A graduate said something about IIM-C and now when an IIM-C graduate replies.. its deleted.. interesting...

  107. Hi!

    I think your post has gotten all this flak because people refuse to be sensitive to the fact that your opinion is your own, and that if we want to read your blog, it is OUR responsibility to judge what we believe.

    Either way, you blogged about what you believe in, and all the IIM-C students (most comments were from disgruntled IIM-C students) just want to show their "loyalty" by going into denial about the major issues you raised in your post. Just because IIM-C still gets placements does not mean it is not becoming worse. In fact, even if it is improving and doing so at a slower pace than other IIMs or other business schools, it means that in relative terms, the school is still becoming worse.

    I would want the IIM-C administration to address these issues, but somehow our alumni/alma-mater loyalty in India tends to skew simply to "mera school sabse accha hai" mentality. Just because some things are fine, doesn't mean everything is.

    Good going Rashmi, I read your blog regularly, and will continue to do so. Don't let the comments of a few pseudo-politically-correct students pull you down.

    - Vishal Nehru

  108. What does having a 90% bengali faculty profile be a negative for IIMC if the faculty is well qualified? Its ridiculous to bring this point into the picture!

    Also regarding the laidback attitude, dont you think it is the students credential that he could achieve lot more or equally so with a little relaxation?

    I am no IIM grad, but hope to be one some day, but such an assessment on your part will not have any bearing on which one I will choose.

  109. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

  110. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

  111. Dear Rashmi,
    I agree Kolkata with its trams wrecking the road suck big time..
    BUT wats the point u r trying to make? In all the IITs+all engg colleges ppl dry their inners outside,does tht make all of them bad...does tht mean the education n the fight ppl put it in is not worth it??
    I think Mr Arjun Singh needs to address the undy drying issues than the present egalitarian eduction propaganda hes on these days.and to top it the FT times worldwide MBA ranking should include a new coloumn of a criteria of "Visibility of drying undergarments" adjacent to the avg salary in $.. et al..maybe who knows they have already incorporated it without displaying it in the list (n thts y i wonder y any of the IIMs have never figured in the top 100 list of FT despite all major recruiters coming here)
    btw i am using my frens id as i dont have no point tracing back
    as for ur ABC comparisons i want to tell u, the company i am working in is a day1 company across A,B,C for aeons(i am just a graduate so cant have a bias)..C guys are taken specifically for finance based functions like treasuries, M&A,Business planning where they r doing gr8 work and the A guys are taken more for marketing and business development functions n identifying new markets n both are equally imp n they excel in their respective fields and r equally given respect(along with
    Infact if i do MBA i would take C if i want finance else A for marketing. So Ma'am theres nothing like whch is better..
    IIM is known as a single brand to the outside world and let us keep it tht way(same applies to IITs) instead of this "meri gf jyaada toat hai" slogan else we wont b able to break in to the ivy league standards.

  112. @koolvibsflyinghigh
    "If you dont know Bengali in Kolkata, then you are gone because people dont want to communicate in any other language." -- crap !!
    you knw wht?? u ve totally wrong idea abt Cal.. every Bong may nt be able to speak Hindi fluently.. but atleast they r able to understand it n ll def try to reply ur query, they watch hindi movies as much as they watch bengali movies.. u ve stated very wrongly abt Kol Mr Kool...

    o ya Bongs r highly intellectual :) but thts not a pt to be highlighted.. we r Indians.. thts it..
    i never saw IIT-ians comparing themselves? y do IIM-ites need to?? after all IITs n IIMs are 'd premier' institutes of our country!

  113. Rashmi,

    Your post was ridiculous. I dont see the reason behind your article. If you are an IIM-A alumni, the institute must have imbibed in a feeling of welfare for the country as whole. I can bet they never teach to endorse IIM-A and make a mockery of other IIMs! I dont know what special elevtive you took to have this stuff in your mind. It would have been great if you would have talked about the beauty of taking something from others! For that matter the executive developmetn pgm you talked about! Is it something to feel shy of, when we take something good from somewhere and master it better than others? I dont who is better but I dont see any point in making this statement by you!

    >And what you wanted to prove by that drying underwear stuff! I guess you also live like normal human being and you wash your clothes and hang them for drying somwhere! I wont like to make a statement against any IIM for that matter. But where do you hang your clothes for drying? Do you hang them in your cupboard and lock it?

    >And yes whats the point of having all Bong Profs? DO you have any problems. Anyone can see a racist in you from that statement. I guess you forgot that intellectuals are supposed to stand for India and not Kolkata or Ahmedabad like you standing. I guess by your statements, some regional outfits my contact you for advocating their interest. Can you see a repercussion of your statement! How come you earned your degree from such a prestigious institute?

    > Well, architecture and building. Point well made. But ywould you like to read in an institute which has worst faculty nothing to teach but has a 5 start campus! Well, a good campus, high-tech and swanky is needed by everyone but not at the cost of the real thing for which it is setup and I guess that is EDUCATION! You should see that the recruiters dont come to see the buildings from all over the world bu to hire talent! They have great buildings than any educational institute here! DO you think that matters most! It would have been great if you would have dealt with this point in a manner to point out that the buildings are old but the people are there who make anything livelier! You know more than I do about how you could have handled this point!







  115. It was fun reading the post. Didnt have time to read the comments. Guess those would be full of people throwing mud at each other. By the way, would be joining IIMC this June..still a great read..and some great issues addressed.

    Thumbs up!!

  116. @koolvibswhoever

    If you wear shades in the night, this is what you get. Kolkata is not a metropolitan city you say. I shouldn't argue. For an individual whose intelligence allows him a blogger name called koolvibsflyinghigh, spelling Kolkata properly, I think is a great feat in itself.

  117. Anonymous9:31 AM

    减速机 齿轮减速机 SEW减速机 摆线针轮减速机 蜗轮蜗杆减速机 interlining
    明星代言 明星经纪公司
    制动单元 铝壳电阻
    modern abstract art sofa manufacturer
    净水器 开水器 净水机 净水 软水机 软水 直饮机 家用净水 家用净水器 家用净水机 中央净水 中央净水器 水家装 水家电 水卫士 混合机
    过滤机 DHL快递 俄罗斯签证 回转支承 Laser marking
    保险箱 法兰 法兰标准
    polycarbonate sheet 回流焊 波峰焊
    压球机 注册上海公司 儿童摄影
    牛皮癣 皮肤病 制氮机
    食堂售餐机 校园一卡通
    学校一卡通 ic卡售饭机
    食堂售饭机 深圳一卡通
    广东售饭机 机电设备安装
    北京发票 代开发票
    餐饮发票 住宿发票
    网络电话 免费网络电话
    假发 补发
    织发 植发
    压滤机 板框压滤机
    蒸馏水机 纯蒸气发生器
    上海搬家公司 上海搬场公司
    大众搬家 大众搬场
    张家界旅游 香港旅游
    深圳旅行社 打包机
    收缩机 对讲机 电源模块
    售饭机 水控机 水控器
    萎缩性胃炎 neoprene laptop bags
    SEO优化 计量泵
    胃炎 胃病
    冷水机 冰水机
    北京特价机票 北京打折计票 北京国际机票
    北京机票预定 北京飞机票
    北京订机票 北京机票查询 饮料机械
    银杏 水培花卉 企业宣传片 空分设备
    化工泵 离心机
    电话交换机 程控交换机 集团电话 集装袋
    混合机 混合机
    混合机捏合机 捏合机
    捏合机导热油炉 导热油炉
    导热油炉 反应釜 反应釜
    反应釜 spherical roller bearing
    搬运车 搬运车 电动搬运车 油桶搬运车 堆高车 电动堆高车 半电动堆高车 堆垛车
    高空作业平台车 电动叉车 平衡重叉车 前移叉车 电瓶叉车
    韩国饰品批发 模块电源
    X架 超薄灯箱> 易拉宝 展柜制作
    代理服务器 游戏加速器 网络加速器
    网通加速器 电信加速器 电信网通转换器
    电信网通加速器 网通电信互转
    网通电信互通 网络游戏加速器
    美国VPN代理 美国独享VPN 美国独享IP
    pvc ceiling panel Spherical roller bearings
    安全鞋 劳保鞋 防砸鞋 电绝缘鞋 上海安全鞋 上海劳保鞋 江苏劳保鞋
    服装软件 服装管理软件 进销存软件
    进销存管理软件 服装管理系统 服装进销存软件
    进销存系统 进销存管理系统 免费进销存软件
    吉林中医 东北特产
    阳痿 阴茎短小 阴茎增大
    早泄 前列腺炎 阴茎增粗 阴茎延长
    国际机票 上海国际机票
    国际特价机票 国际打折机票
    砂磨机 砂磨机
    砂磨机 卧式砂磨机
    卧式砂磨机 卧式砂磨机
    三辊研磨机 三辊研磨机
    三辊研磨机 混合机 混合机
    混合机 锥形混合机 锥形混合机 锥形混合机 行星动力混合机 行星动力混合机 行星动力混合机 无重力混合机 无重力混合机 无重力混合机
    干粉砂浆设备 干粉砂浆设备
    干粉砂浆设备 捏合机 捏合机 捏合机 导热油炉 导热油炉 导热油炉 反应釜 反应釜 反应釜 搪玻璃反应釜 搪玻璃反应釜 搪玻璃反应釜
    乳化机 涂料设备 干混砂浆设备 无重力混合机 胶体磨 涂料成套设备 双螺旋混合机
    北京婚庆 北京婚庆公司
    办证 呼吸机 制氧机
    亚都 亚都加湿器 亚都净化器
    饰品批发 小饰品批发 韩国饰品 韩国饰品批发 premature ejaculation penis enlargement
    安利产品 马来西亚留学
    网站优化 网站推广
    论文代写 代写论文
    拖链 防护罩 排屑机 塑料拖链 钢铝拖链
    深圳装饰 深圳装饰公司 深圳装修公司
    特价机票 打折机票 国际机票
    新风换气机 换气机 立式新风换气机 风机箱 新风系统 能量回收机
    搅拌机 混合机 乳化机
    毛刷 毛刷辊 工业毛刷 刷子 钢丝刷
    涂层测厚仪 硬度计
    兆欧表 激光测距仪
    测振仪 转速表
    温湿度计 风速仪
    噪音计 红外测温仪
    硬度计 万用表
    美容院 美容加盟
    澳洲留学 澳大利亚留学
    酒店预定 北京酒店预定 北京酒店
    nail equipment nail products nail product nail uv lamp nail uv lamp nail uv lamps uv nail lamp nail brush
    nail file nail tool nail tip nail gel curing uv lamps lights
    万用表 风速仪
    红外测温仪 噪音计
    苗木价格 苗木信息 标牌制作 深圳标牌 北京儿童摄影 防静电鞋 淘宝刷信誉
    威海凤凰湖 威海海景房 大庆密封件
    打标机 淘宝刷信誉 TESOL/TEFL国际英语教师证书 英语教师进修及培训 北京快递公司 北京国际快递

  118. Nice post. Being an old hand, I remember the days when IIM B was a new school and IIM C and A were the places to be. How things change...

  119. IIMA started its PGPX program on the heels of ISB then. whatdya say bout that? :P

  120. Anonymous8:29 AM

    ^^ nice blog!! ^@^

    徵信, 徵信網, 徵信社, 徵信社, 徵信社, 徵信社, 感情挽回, 婚姻挽回, 挽回婚姻, 挽回感情, 徵信, 徵信社, 徵信, 徵信, 捉姦, 徵信公司, 通姦, 通姦罪, 抓姦, 抓猴, 捉猴, 捉姦, 監聽, 調查跟蹤, 反跟蹤, 外遇問題, 徵信, 捉姦, 女人徵信, 女子徵信, 外遇問題, 女子徵信, 徵信社, 外遇, 徵信公司, 徵信網, 外遇蒐證, 抓姦, 抓猴, 捉猴, 調查跟蹤, 反跟蹤, 感情挽回, 挽回感情, 婚姻挽回, 挽回婚姻, 外遇沖開, 抓姦, 女子徵信, 外遇蒐證, 外遇, 通姦, 通姦罪, 贍養費, 徵信, 徵信社, 抓姦, 徵信, 徵信公司, 徵信社, 徵信, 徵信公司, 徵信社, 徵信公司, 女人徵信, 外遇

    徵信, 徵信網, 徵信社, 徵信網, 外遇, 徵信, 徵信社, 抓姦, 徵信, 女人徵信, 徵信社, 女人徵信社, 外遇, 抓姦, 徵信公司, 徵信社, 徵信社, 徵信社, 徵信社, 徵信社, 女人徵信社, 徵信社, 徵信, 徵信社, 徵信, 女子徵信社, 女子徵信社, 女子徵信社, 女子徵信社, 徵信, 徵信社, 徵信, 徵信社, 徵信, 徵信社, 徵信, 徵信社, 徵信, 徵信社, 徵信,

    徵信, 徵信社,徵信, 徵信社, 徵信, 徵信社, 徵信, 徵信社, 徵信, 徵信社, 徵信, 徵信社, 徵信, 徵信社, 徵信, 徵信社, 徵信, 徵信社, 徵信, 徵信社, 徵信, 徵信社, 徵信, 徵信社, 徵信, 徵信社, 徵信, 徵信社, 徵信, 徵信社, 徵信, 徵信社, 徵信, 徵信社, 外遇, 抓姦, 離婚, 外遇,離婚,

    徵信, 外遇, 離婚, 徵信社, 徵信, 外遇, 抓姦, 徵信社, 徵信, 徵信社, 徵信, 外遇, 徵信社, 徵信, 外遇, 抓姦, 徵信社, 征信, 征信, 徵信, 徵信社, 徵信, 徵信社, 征信, 徵信, 徵信社, 徵信, 徵信, 徵信社, 徵信, 徵信社, 徵信社, 徵信社, 徵信, 外遇, 抓姦, 徵信, 徵信社, 徵信, 徵信社, 徵信,

  121. Anonymous11:22 AM

    Now, Surat has its own website which provides complete information about the city. There are

    large numbers of information which are Surat city related. If you want to know about the business

    information of the city, you can also get that information. Apart from that, we have a special feature in this website, Social Networking in which

    you can add your profile as well as you can also add your business page.

  122. Top website designing company in India, Surat provding world class design and solutions.Website Design Surat, Surat Website Designing Company, Webpage Designing Surat, Surat Web Development

  123. maybe its just ain't a coincidence that certain b schools r more into habit of producing attention mongers... chetan bhagat being one...along with the author of this blog !

  124. I just converted my IIM A call and will join this year. I think that we are comparing two great institutions here and they are both at the top of their game. As far as rankings go, well those are crap. I can say this because I am a student of a NIT (Surat) and I see musical chair being played with the rankings every year, whether its engg colleges or bschools. As for me, it wouldnt have made much of a diff to me if I would join A or C. As for the 75% attendance thing, i guess its a matter of choice.

  125. But, to a dispassionate and outside eye, there is a lot that can and must be done to the campus.

    The problem is, you wont be seen as a dispassionate eye. The article is inconsequential. totally.

  126. Great post, this article contains how marketing should be done, will save post and share. website seo company

  127. Anonymous4:17 PM

    This comment has been removed by the author.


Disqus for Youth Curry - Insight on Indian Youth