Tuesday, February 08, 2005

Woh ladki hai kahaan Part 1

Do young women in India enjoy the same freedom and opportunities as young men? Certainly we've come a long long way but have we come far enough? I don't think so.

Yes, education is a 'right' for girls born into middle and upper class families. But at various levels, there's still the implicit understanding that padhna-likhna sab theek hai (studying is a good thing) but acche ghar mein shaadi (marrying into a good family) is of prime importance.

So let's say a young woman completes her graduation and then an MBA - she is about 23 years old. She has just entered a first job. There is much to learn and adjust to. She would like to spend the next few years on building a career. WAIT A MINUTE!

Ladki chaubis ki ho gayi hai (the girl is 24...) Ab to shaadi ka sochna hi padega (Now we parents must think about marriage). Guys? They can safely wait till 28, even 30 and still be considered 'eligible'. And they would essentially be looking for girls 24-25 years old to marry.

Now there are exceptions. Some young women simply put their foot down and don't toe the line. But a majority agree to start 'seeing boys'. Progress is visible on two fronts:
a) The more liberal parents will at least ask 'Koi hai to nahin' (Is there someone you like?) And if the guy is from a decent (similar or better class family) and in well paying job, they are happy enough to agree to the marriage.

In many middle class families, qualification seems to be the most important criteria. Both studied MBA/ engineering together? Great. Punjabi marrying Bengali is OK. Kam se kam Hindu hai na (At least both are Hindus). Now to a non-Indian that might seem parochial but I think it is a LOT less rigid than in the past.

b) Many, many young people are meeting through the internet. While dating sites have a pretty sad ratio of girls: boys (about 1:10 seems to be accepted standard!), matrimonial sites boast a healthy number of girls (and many profiles appear to be registered by the girl herself and not the parents).

Unlike the traditional matrimonial classifieds the online version is much more egalitarian. And builds a certain comfort level. The girl and boy may exchange some emails or have chatted on messenger prior to meeting in person.

Great Expectations
Still the whole process of finding 'a suitable boy' is fraught with tensions and complications. Yes, guys go through it when looking for a girl but not to the same degree. The difference lies in the answer to the question: Will I really be able to pursue my career after marriage?

It's amazing how many families - and guys themselves - want highly qualified wives but see their careers mainly as 'hobbies'. My 25 year old cousin, an MBA and banking professional who is currently meeting prospective grooms has really interesting stories to share.

One guy she met was a software engineer in Gurgaon. His views on women and careers: "The girl can work after marriage but should be home by 5 pm". Uh huh. Like ANY job except school teacher would match that description.

The good thing, I assured her, was he was very honest in stating his expectations upfront. Unlike many others who may pretend to be very supportive before marriage and then make life difficult for you later.

Bottomline is, even my cousin is not a wildly ambitious career woman. But, she says, having slogged to get this far, "I want to be able to make my own choices."

Maybe she will give up her career at some stage and look after home and babies - as many professional women are wont to do the world over. But it should not be because the husband or in-laws decree that.

Double standards continue
As teenagers, girls face far more restrictions. Parents claim to 'trust' daughters yet constantly lay down rules for them that don't apply to their sons. Staying out late with friends, going to parties - these are still areas where double standards apply.

These double standards continue to apply throughout life. Young women should be educated (you see MBA boys want to marry MBA girls!) but they should be willing to compromise when and where necessary. So if your husband is transferred to the US you should not think twice give up your job and move with him.

Yeh sab karna padta hai... the elders remind us.

What young women want to know is: Kya taali donon haathon se nahin bajni chahiye?


  1. Anonymous6:34 AM

    hey rashmi, well thats a good thought. totally echoes my views, but i dont think leaving career jus to make babies is .....er....right!

  2. Anonymous6:34 AM

    well that earlier anonymous comment was mine.....vaibhav.

  3. Nothing can be closer to the truth. Came blog hopping and ended up reading all of this in one go...

  4. Hi....

    I so very well believe with every word u say.I am a media planner and have been looking for the right man for so long now.It so true.Today's men...so superficial and extra smart.
    Even the carrer bit...the categories of today's women are so true.I am so glad that i chanced upon this site.
    Guess i belong to the d category but as u said it...v lonely and unhappy.I see so many of my kinds in my ad agency...

    Anyhow,keep this going.

  5. Anonymous1:07 PM

    Hi Rashmi,

    I do agree with your views, but I do feel that not all Males are like that. I am, for example, prepared not to work and stay at home if my wife(I dont have one now) has a better job.

    And I would always be happy in what she is happy in, whether she wants to work or not

    But what I cannot compromise is the education level, I do want an intelligent brain to share my life and there should not be anything wrong with that. (By the way you can see that link)

  6. Ok. Tell us something new.

  7. Anonymous2:36 AM

    On the part regarding additional restriction on girls, I think part of reasoning here is their wellbeing as well. Considering the crime rate, if parents wants their daughters to come back home early or avoid late night parties, they just want their safety. You can blame male-dominated society for it, but it is as it is.

  8. Anonymous11:49 AM

    You are definitely bang on target. But there are just a list of problems and no solutions for the working women of india. I have a sister who falls into the same category. She is 23, born to a middle-class family of teachers, into her first job in a reputed s/w firm and puts her career first. But how long, I am not too sure. She is yet to find a match on her own and given her social skills i dont think she will ever find one. And given that my parents are conservative and we belong to a backward caste, it will be tough for them to find a "suitable" match. I am a guy touching 30 and they are finding it tough to find me a match. So the things are not looking great on the marriage front. And I am sure, this is the case with most of the "conservative" middle class aspiring population of India - that marriage is their first and biggest compromise.

  9. Dear Rashmi,

    This is my story. I have married my batch mate from MBA college. I was a better performer than him in the college. I ranked in top 15, highly ambitious. And the best part is he knew all this and apparently supported it. But as you after marriage my job and my career has become least important to him. He got posted to UK just before marriage and the bargain laid out in front of me was leave your job and be with me. Since I took a stand and didn’t go with him. I am continuously pressurized for leaving my job, shifting cities. My in laws blame me for his unhappiness without even thinking about me. They all say I surely can do a job but as long as it doesn’t come in their son’s happiness.

    I ask why we allow our girls to study and so dream. All higher education for girls should be banned in India if we can’t appreciate the girls’ right to dream and aspire. Why for a girl it is always made a choice between family and career?



  10. @ Sarika,

    it's sad that even today, such disparities happen to exist in marriages. But as far as your case is concerned, I feel to some extent you were at fault too. The very reason why we marry the one we love is because we wanna live our lives with "our kinda" partners. And I'm very sorry to say, your husband doesn't seem to belong to that kind. And despite belonging to that zilch group of people who are fortunate enough to learn what they have in store for them in future, you went ahead and married this guy. I'm sorry, I ain't trying to justify your husband's actions...I just wrote what I felt about your issue!


Disqus for Youth Curry - Insight on Indian Youth