Monday, October 09, 2006

Mobile Gaming II

My affair with mobile gaming ended when I broke up with 'Snake' while shifting handsets. Truth be told, Snake broke up with me coz it wasn't preloaded on my Nokia 6670.

But after receiving N number of 'service messages' from Hutch exhorting me to download this that or the other wallpaper, ringtone or game, I finally succumbed.

I downloaded the 'Don' game, as per instructions. And guess what? Two files did appear on my phone. Don.jar and Don.jad. But the game refused to install.

So I asked the tech savvy dude and dudette in my office to try and make it happen. After all 20 bucks had been added to my bill... And we were to review the game before the film released, for JAM magazine. No luck.

I don't know if my experience was a common one. Or not. Certainly I have no energy to chase up the 20 lost rupees. For a game I suspect may not be all that hot anyways...

Next-generation mobile gaming
A young lady who owns the amazing Nokia N70 recently gave me a crash course in mobile gaming.

"See, this is an Indian game" and she turned up her nose. " Really sad..." The game was "Rei's love adventure" by Mauj. Here's how the intro of the game goes : (reproduced exactly)

"Rei the lovely flower girl want this year Valentine Days to be special. She want to give something special as Valentine gift to her boyfriend. She heard there are a lot of special item hidden in the maze garden but people said you cannot stay too long in the garden or you will get lost foreverin there. Please help Rei find all the items in the maze garden so her Valentine's Day will be the most special day she ever had."

As if that were not lame enough the game itself is a snake adaptation where a Hello-Kitty kind of girl-character goes around collecting hearts. And there is no challenge in terms of higher levels, speed, or difficulty either.

I can see even my 7 year old daughter getting bored of this in a jiffy.

"Now here are the really cool games..." and on screen appeared 'Da Vinci Code'. This game follows the plot and characters of the movie - you have to unlock the secrets hidden in the game. But there are some which are not in the book/ film so there is an element of surprise.

The game is mainly strategy/ role play but in level 2 there is a chase so that's where the action part is also brought in. Graphics are decent - in fact the game feels closer to a PC game. At least the kind of PC games you had not too long ago!

Other games recommended to me:

Pirates of the Carribean (it's not based on the movie plot though). And of course the PC classics adapted for the mobile such as Need for Speed, Carmageddon ( it has a multiplayer option via bluetooth), Doom, and Prince of Persia.

And oh, an additional tip. Playing games on phones with joystick controls is hard unless you have long nails. "In the N series, the power button is very close to the joustick. If you press it accidentally, power gaya, game gaya... You have start all over again."

So where do you get these games? You have to know the right people and join a closed user group or 'forum' dedicated to swapping and sharing. I'm sure there are sites on the net from where you can download them as well.

"These games are not officially available in India " says the N70 girl. "So I guess it's OK to get them this way. " It's a moot point whether folks would pay if it were officially available.

The 'potential'
All I know is, mobile gaming may be 'set to explode' in India according to industry analysts. I've written about the figures being thrown about in a previous post.

Given the number of mobile handsets and demand for entertainment/ timepass, there is a lot of potential. But I don't see the potential being achieved unless Indian companies:

a) Produce compelling international quality content. With the Bollywood footprint spreading across the world, I see no reason why a game based on a desi movie should not rival Da Vinci code in terms of graphics and challenge.

Quick and dirty won't work as more and more people upgrade to better quality phones in the next 2-3 years. Pirated versions of foreign games will trickle down from the cool and the 'know where to get it' types, to almost everyone.

b) The other model could be to sell basic, but very cheap and disposable content (games for 2 bucks each - you can play them just a couple of times and feel paisa vasool ho gaya).

Even here it's not just price but the fact that downloading, installing and playing consumes time and energy. I don't want 'faltu' stuff. Right now most developers are talking about the number of games they have made...Not that they actually sell any one in large quantities!

Most games get a mere 7-10,000 downloads in India. I know they also earn small amounts by licensing in to a large number of non-Indian operators and thus it works as a business.

The single largest selling title that I am aware of (excluding free R world downloads) is Sholay. It had 150,000 downloads by March 2006, according to a report published by the Internet and Mobile Association of India (IAMAI).

To my mind, it would be wiser to have fewer game titles but better quality. Perhaps I am mistaken and 'quality' does exist - but frankly, I as the end user simply do not have the information about it.

The gaming companies can themselves identify and promote select titles which have wide appeal. Additionally, they should send out mobile games to be previewed and/ or reviewed by the media - the way audio companies send CDs or movie companies invite journalists to press shows. Given that youth is the target audience, even bloggers could be enlisted.

The point being if the game is good, the ensuing positive recommendations will drive downloads. And if it's bad, well, those are the games which could be sold cheaply. And feedback would be valuable when developing games in the future.

And now, over to their websites...
Certainly, both developers and operators could provide a lot more on their websites. If you don't showcase your wares attractively how do you expect people to buy them?

The Hutch site is really bland - no indication of what the graphics might look like. Just a single screenshot and text description.

The Mauj site is a little better, but not enough. Take this game I randomly picked, based on KANK . There is no mention of how much it might cost me - Rs 20, 50, or 99? And would it really hurt if you let me see a simulation of the gameplay online, so I can decide if I like it enough to pay??

As for this site - it has not been updated in a while. Main hoon na wallpapers are a little out of demand right now. Also, you can't download anything ... Or did I miss something ?

Similarly, Mobile2win showcases
250 + games but it's not clear how I can download them. As the R world logo is prominently displayed, perhaps they supply content in India exclusively to Reliance and use the site to display their wares to operators abroad who may wish to license it for other countries.

But all is not lost. Indiagames is a site with a difference. It's well designed, with prices clearly listed. Some attempt is made to showcase gameplay - check the Krrish game under 'Bollywood'. Not sure if people would pay 99 bucks if jumping up and down is all there is to it.. but letting us see what the action looks like is a huge step forward!

Another great feature with Indiagames is that when you register, you are eligible to download 5 free games. And no, they don't appear to be duds.There's Championship Cricket, F Speed Forge (a racing game) and character based games like Buffy the Vampire Slayer and Phantom.

What's more, instead of me having to send an sms to a short code number, the moment I click on download, Indiagames sends me an sms with a link to download the free game of my choice vis gprs.

I think Indiagames approach is the right one - this will help develop the market and build a longer term relationship with the consumer. This is how you reach out to more people, give them a taste of a new kind of thumb candy. When enough people like what they've tasted, they'll pay for more and there you have a 'gaming culture'.

One additional feature Indiagames should add is forums or allow Amazon-style user comments. I think that would add a lot of value. Ideally, we should have an independent and dedicated mobile gaming website like this one.

As I write this, I haven't actually been able to download my free Indiagames game because the 'web server is busy'. But hey, I shall keep trying :)

As for Don... if any one of you has managed to download that one, let me know if I missed anything! And yeah, anyone who'd like to review mobile games for JAM on a regular basis - do get in touch.

16 comments:

  1. http://www.mummy-papa.blogspot.com/

    Nice Job!!!

    ReplyDelete
  2. You need to have a Java Support for your phone...The technical specs of 6670 do mention a Java Support! I dont know why didnt the game install!!

    By the way, Excellent and well researched article from a "customer" POV !!

    ReplyDelete
  3. If the games were free and supported by advertising , they would be more popular

    ReplyDelete
  4. Well, gaming in India is evolving. There are hardly any decent content companies. Moreover, look at the Java-enabled mobile revolution. It has happened in the last few years only. So maybe it will take time for content companies to come up with speed.
    Though I must say that your reviews are well researched!!
    Ashish
    iDea Labs

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi i like ur way of writing visit my blog at http://nabasho.blogspot.com/

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi Rashmi,

    Excellent piece, as always. I've been following your blog for the past few months, and I've consistently found myself agreeing with many of your viewpoints. (Well, except for your film review ratings - you're far too kind there :-)

    With mobile games, as with gaming in India in general, the challenge for the gamewallahs, at least the way I see it, is in how do they want to treat the games they offer - as a service or as a commodity. Even if they're treating them as a commodity, to be churned out, sold in enough numbers and then forgotten as their attention shifts to the next product, it is to their advantage to produce games with compelling content, and ease of use. However, wouldn't it be wiser for them to treat what they offer as a service? Here's a great chance for a game company to build a brand based on qualities like comfort, reliability, ease of use, courtesy and prompt attention in case of problems experienced, etc. If any of these companies can crack this (and Indiagames might have a lead start, from what you write), then they go beyond being mere content providers... they become entertainment brands in their own right. And in an era of choice, if I'm ecstatic with one gaming experience chances are that I'm going to continue patronizing the brand that provides me with that experience - just like I do with my airline, or hotel, or favourite film director.

    Herein lies the challenge for the Maujs and the Indiagames of today... they need to stop thinking small, really focus on brand building - and reimagine themselves from a neighbourhood tailor mentality (making salwar suits for aunties and didis) to that of a Westside or Provogue or Polo Ralph Lauren.

    ReplyDelete
  7. They must be made free so that all can afford in india. It is good people are glued to itand forget their daily work

    ReplyDelete
  8. nice one..n as sudeep said ur write up had d "Customer POV" ..as an avid PC gamer with a short experience of mobile gaming (thnx 2 mumbai rains 2 whom i lost my n6600), i do realize dat cos cud do well by :
    1)building brands, so dat they can get customer attention n thus better deals with mobile operators.

    2)They shud use in-game advertising as most of the big PC game development house do (pick any of EA sport games n u'll know what m i talking of)

    these will help them get d initial funding required 4 brand building (besides the usual VC or PE route)

    ReplyDelete
  9. They must be made free so that all can afford in india. It is good people are glued to itand forget their daily work

    ReplyDelete
  10. Check out www.hovr.com, they are offering lot of free mobile games. You can download free cell phone games, all you need to do is just sign up.

    ReplyDelete
  11. hey rashmi please link exchange with me . i m aryan garg from new delhi .
    please link exchange with me .

    my site is based on pc games and i provide free games to my readers when they demand.
    http://lonelygames.blogspot.com

    ReplyDelete
  12. please add my blog as free full pc games

    thank you in advance

    ReplyDelete
  13. Social learning theory has been applied to a wide variety of criminal, delinquent, and deviant behavior.
    -------------------------
    pandreson

    Social Media Marketing

    ReplyDelete
  14. There are several other aspects of contemporary youth culture covered in The State of Cool, a compilation of data from five major insight studies across the globe. According to Aditya Swamy, VP – ad sales & marketing, MTV, the research wing was rebranded and has been oriented to digging deeper and going beyond numbers. While the target audience was predominantly in the 15 to 24 age group in urban India, there are also some findings from MTV’s International Well Being Study that tracked the 16 to 34 age bracket.
    -----------------------------------
    Jonty rodes

    Internet Marketing

    ReplyDelete
  15. A year after Google bought feed ad network FeedBurner for a rumored $100 million, FeedBurner's death was announced informally in a Google Groups thread. Publishers are expected to use Google's own AdSense instead.
    ------------------------
    hennry

    ethical seo

    ReplyDelete
  16. Also check this site is also offering a great collection of mobile games


    Free Mobile Games

    ReplyDelete

Disqus for Youth Curry - Insight on Indian Youth